It is fashionable to blame America for all that we see in the Middle East today. It is fashionable as well to blame it on oil, on Saudis and Qataris and Jordanians and Egyptians – not to say the Israelis.
The brutal images of children killed in Gaza by Israelis are undeniable; just like it is undeniable that Muslim children by 10, or 100, or maybe 1,000 times more have been killed, maimed, and slaughtered by Muslims in the past decades. You may not have seen those on Facebook because they were not killed by Jews or Christians.
When Muslims kill/maim/brutalise other Muslims, it is convenient to blame the US/West. People blame the US because they supplied the arms or because they have in the past supported one or the other or both sides. It is like blaming God for creating us. I am sure if God had not created us, none of these events would have happened. But at the end it is we, Muslims, who are to blame. Not God, not the US, not Israel, and not oil.
They are all contributing factors, including God, but the root cause is the misguided interpretation of the religion – Islam – that has given a moral umbrella to millions of people who have shown utter lack of any feeling while slaughtering their fellow Muslims because they believe in the long run Allah will take them to heaven for their Jihad.
What we also should be blaming is the apathy that has been shown by billions of moderate Muslims, practicing (including myself) or non-practicing, to address some fundamental issues related to Islam and to bring it to the 20th century (and then 21st). If not addressed, in the long term it will result in the demise of the world as we know it, far before the increasing carbon-levels can harm us.
Let us start with ISIS and look at what is happening in Iraq today and how it has evolved. If you have to blame somebody contemporary for what ISIS is doing, blame it on Obama and Maliki. If you are looking to blame somebody for the root cause, blame the interpretation of Islam. The main cause of this is centuries old: Imam Ali, Imam Mehdi, and the Shia-Sunni conflict.
Protestants and Catholics have solved their conflict. We Muslims are about 1,000 years behind in solving ours, and there is no sign that it is getting any better. ISIS may not have the support but they represent the anger and the fear of the 20% Sunni population of Iraq who were disenfranchised by Maliki, the day Obama forced the military to leave Iraq and let Iraqis govern themselves.
Years before that, when Paul Bremer left Iraq and left governance to locals, the Iraqi vice president, a Sunni (and a Bath party loyalist), was charged with crimes of operating a death squad and sentenced to death (resulting in him then fleeing to Turkey).
Since then, Maliki has systematically destroyed what Bremer and Petraeus were craftily building – which was ensuring that Sunnis would have a voice in the Iraqi government. The “surge” that brought in additional troops helped Petraeus force Maliki and the Shias to accommodate the Sunnis. Since the departure of the US troops, this delicate balance was destroyed. Is the US to be blamed for the creation of ISIS? In a way. Let us see why and how.
The sectarian violence that plagued Iraq in 2011 was finally managed by General Petraeus who bought off the Sunni insurgents ($400m) and created the “Son of Iraq” brigade – which eventually evolved into ISIS. Petraus was able to reduce Iraqi-on-Iraqi violence by almost 90%.
Petraeus, a Princeton PhD, is an expert in counterinsurgency. He knew that the only way to address the sectarian violence, which was claiming more than a thousand lives a month, was to arm and buy both the Sunni insurgents (Son of Iraq brigade) and the Shia Insurgents (Mahadi brigade – the aftermath of the Fallujah war). Petraeus’s policy was to let the two groups police themselves and keep enough pressure on the Maliki government so that they would not oppress the Sunnis the same way Saddam oppressed the Shias for decades.
This strategy worked as long as the US troops were there. The day US troops left, Maliki was able to do whatever he wanted – and he decided to start brutally oppressing the Sunni population. So much so that in just two years, hardliner Sunnis of the Son of Iraq group erupted in what you see today as the march of ISIS.
So now, how about the other fashionable argument? “If Bush had not invaded Iraq, then 100,000 Iraqi civilians would not have been killed and what we see now would not have happened.” Well, maybe not now, but it absolutely would have happened eventually. Saddam brutalised the majority of Shias in a way that, once again, makes me say that it makes the Israeli brutality look tame.
And it was a matter of time, years, or decades, that the brutal oppression by Saddam and the Sunnis would have been met with equal brutality from Shias, and millions would have died. History shows that. This is what happened in the 80-88 Iran-Iraq war: Millions died, were maimed and gassed with no gain to show any resolve to the Shia-Sunni conflict.
Yes, once again, it’s fashionable to say that the US tacitly gave approval to Saddam to start the Iraq invasion of Iran in 1980 and thereby is to blame. However, if you have to blame the US, then blame Allah for creating man. Blame the Prophets, the ones who have created religion, blame Imam Ali and the others who had led to the Sunni-Shia divide.
There is a lot of blame to go around, but none absolve the parties from their own personal responsibilities and the fact that Islam, as a religion, has not evolved, as well as the fact that “moderate Muslims” have done very little to address this.
They went along with their merry lives, showing moral outrage from time to time through Facebook posts and boycotts when Jews or Christians kill Muslims, and then blame the US, Israel, and the West when Muslims kill Muslims with an order of magnitude more ferociousness and brutality.
The carnage that we see now in the entire Muslim world can only be addressed if we, the billions of Muslims, rise up and say enough is enough. Enough with the finger-pointing at the West, at the US, and at Israel. When you point a finger at someone, there are always three fingers pointing at you. What are we going to do to stop a religion that is being taken over by millions of fanatics and simply observed by billions of people who are content with the status quo?
How Islam is interpreted and applied in many countries and within many religious communities must change for humanity to survive and prosper. Every religion has gone through this phase. There was a time when working on a Sunday in the US was a crime, because according to scripture, it is the day of the Sabbath. But with time, religion, like everything, has evolved, and now it is time for Islam to evolve to bring peace to the region and to the world.