About a fortnight ago, one of the more vocal and formerly communist ministers of the current regime went on a finger wagging episode at a ruling party conclave, where she proceeded to lecture the US ambassador-designate to Bangladesh about diplomatic proprieties. The ire of the former communist was raised because Ambassador-designate Bernicat gave her testimony to the United States Senate about the State Department’s perception of the January 5 electoral exercise in Bangladesh.
Notwithstanding what one thinks of the prudence of the manner in which the January 5 elections were conducted, the minister’s outburst is sadly reflective of the utter lack of understanding in the highest circles about how American government in general, and foreign policy in particular, works.
Unlike in regimes where there really isn’t much of a difference between the executive and the legislative branches outside of the lofty words of constitutional documents, the United States takes those lines of demarcations very seriously. Ambassador Bernicat’s responses were neither voluntary nor egotistical: Under the penalty of law, she was required to provide her honest assessment, backed up by evidence, to the United States Senate as part of the process to be confirmed as ambassador to Bangladesh.
Ministers and other opinion makers – as is evident from multiple statements across the pages of newspapers regularly – rarely fathom how different Washington DC is from Dhaka or Yangon or Riyadh when it comes to making foreign policy. President Obama is powerful, but he shares that power with a co-equal Congress, which can be a major power-broker when controlled partly, as it is now, by the other party.
I bring this up to portray a major drawback in Bangladesh’s engagement with the United States: Whether due to a lack of knowledge or sheer intellectual laziness, opinion makers in Dhaka simply assume that it is a one-person show in every other capital as well. This myopia results in all the overtures, diplomatic and otherwise, being directed to the presidential administration which has a rather limited ability to respond.
Oversight of foreign policy, funding of foreign aid and operations, visa regimes, and ratification of trade agreements are largely in the purview of several Congressional committees in Washington, and generally independent of the president. These committees themselves are often influenced by interest groups, trade associations, and media perceptions.
It is no surprise, therefore, that countries with a well-developed sense of the American government spend tremendous amount of material and human resources cultivating members of Congress, key media outlets, and civic society organisations in the United States rather than put all their eggs in the singular basket of a president’s administration.
Hiring a one-off lobbyist is often not a substitute for widespread and organic engagement with all the levers of the Washington DC foreign policy establishment. In fairness, this lack of understanding of the ways of Washington is not limited to the ruling party; not too many weeks go by without some member of an opposition party or Dhaka talk show host bemoaning how “Obama” has done this or that good or bad in foreign policy.
The compelling fact remains that when it comes to the shaping of American foreign policy, the president and his administration form the most important driver of the same but hardly the only important driver. There is a reason that even countries and political organisations far smaller than Bangladesh actively and regularly reach out to policy shapers like members and staff of Congress, trade bodies, think tanks, and media outlets to create favorable opinion.
As for Bangladesh, well the first “Bangladesh Caucus” in Congress wasn’t launched till about 10 years ago, and has largely remained dormant for the lack of much engagement from the Bangladeshi side. There is no qualified individual(s) who is tasked by the government or the opposition or even major trade bodies to liaise exclusively with interested members of Congress, and the Bangladeshi presence on the American media circuit – in stark contrast to Indian, Pakistani, and Sri Lankan counterparts – is nonexistent.
The only serious and recent think tank material concerning Bangladesh came out three years ago, and that too was crafted by the daughter of a former minister in a previous Awami League government. The young author’s placement at the said right-wing think tank was fuelled by an earlier monograph which was largely a rather exaggerated recollection of her father’s supposed struggle for a secular democracy, a claim that failed the proverbial smell test considering the author’s father served once in the cabinet of a military dictator who enshrined a state religion in the Constitution.
Like the United States or hate it, it is the predominant superpower in terms of military might, the largest market for most products, the preferred destination for scholars and researchers in almost every field, and the primary purveyor of global popular culture.
If you don’t believe me, look at the current who is who in Bangladesh: From the prime minister to half the cabinet to the editors of the top circulation Bengali and English dailies, where did their children go to school and reside now? Sophisticated engagement with America is not an option, but a necessity for countries, organisations, businesses, and individuals.
Governments, political parties, academic institutions, journalists, and civic and trade bodies serve their constituents poorly when such engagement is based upon a warped misunderstanding of how policymaking in America works.
That a barely-reformed communist would reflexively bash an incoming American ambassador is understandable; that a supposedly “digital” government and an information savvy civil society will have no clue how Washington DC works is pitiful. Such cluelessness ill serves the millions whose livelihoods and careers depend, directly or indirectly, upon successful engagement with the world’s biggest economic and cultural entity.