A pictorial has recently been going around on Facebook, appealing to Bangladeshi television audiences for raising voices against airing a few foreign channels in this country. The names of Zee Bangla, Star Jalsha, and Star Plus have been mentioned in the message.
Wanting to prevent foreign, especially Indian, TV channels is a common phenomenon in our social discourse. Our table-talks are always comprised of this thought – to ban the channels that we think are not appropriate for our society or business.
Recently, two TV channels that had obtained permission to air the FIFA World Cup somehow convinced the cable operators not to transmit the Indian channel, which was also showing the tournament. They thought perhaps Bangladeshi audiences may not watch the local channels if the Indian one was still on.
The strategy worked for them, but the audiences were quite annoyed. As a member of the audience, I will watch any TV that I want to. Why would anyone prevent me from watching the channels that I like? This practice, sometimes, looks quite annoying.
Now what happened to Zee Bangla, Star Jalsha, and Star Plus? A few online news portals say these channels might be taken off air from August 6. Why would we want to take them off air in Bangladesh? Our common realisations about these TV channels haven’t been positive. The drama serials that are broadcast from these TV stations don’t, perhaps, match the social values that we try to uphold.
The stories of these TV dramas mostly revolve around extramarital relationships. It has been alleged that these stories have captured the attention of the Bangladeshi audiences.
From housemaids to teenagers to grandmas, everyone remains glued to these channels when they are being aired. The reason is simple. Forbidden, unjust, secret relationships or whatever we call them, have always had a universal appeal and curiosity.
The question is whether these stories on Indian TV channels are influencing our minds. Are we becoming prone to imitate the lives of the characters that we’re watching on the screen? Yes, it’s a possibility. I remember an English-language series titled Friends on Star World. This show had almost brainwashed many of our teenagers with a phoney notion of friendship in the Western world. We took a long time to fathom that the stories of “friends” are not a true portrayal of their society. But we didn’t want to ban Star World at that time.
Having said that, we have to admit that as far as the TV industry is concerned, we have miserably failed to draw the attention of our own audience. The quality of television dramas are a ready example of this fact. We once had great dramas created by our own great playwrights. Would you prefer Bojhey Na Shey Bojhey Na to any drama of late Humayun Ahmed, or Syed Shamsul Haq?
I don’t believe so. These writers didn’t focus on extramarital themes for tickling the minds of the audience, but we still watched their dramas. I remember the entire nation used to sit before the TV sets when it was time for a Humayun Ahmed serial.
We need to do some soul-searching about the quality of on-air products that we’re creating. Anybody and everybody are becoming playwrights and drama directors.
The industry has grown, but we still worry about Indian channels hijacking our audience. Isn’t it our failure that we could not come up with good stories that would retain the audience?
Sometimes, we try copying Indian channels. I remember a local serial, Gulshan Avenue, which successfully drew quite a large audience. My media friends keep telling me that they are suffering from the lack of good stories. If that’s the case, why aren’t we organising story-writing competitions?
We sometimes underestimate the power of the common audience. On part of the government, our cultural ministry or any other body has, perhaps, never given any thought to this matter. But it’s time to do so.
Banning TV channels may be a strategic move for the sake of our own interests, but at the end of the day, the move may not succeed. If you ban them, these shows will become more lucrative to a Bangla audience. Then, the smugglers will begin to sell pirated CDs of those serials. The ultimate goal wouldn’t be achieved.
Banning doesn’t work when it comes to the media. What we could do is get people truly capable of making dramas and programs, so that our audience prefers our channels more than the foreign ones. We really need to prepare for it.