Many were surprised by the fact that there wasn’t really a public upheaval with the demise of electoral democracy in Bangladesh early this year. The opposition, opposition-leaning intellectuals, and the media, had been screaming from every rooftop in Bangladesh that the people of the country would overthrow this, otherwise truly put, undemocratic regime soon, with popular uprising. But the upheaval hasn’t yet happened, and it doesn’t seem forthcoming.
Simply the absence of any public outburst on the manner the last one-sided parliamentary election was won by the incumbent, does not ascribe any political legitimacy to the current government. Rather, there are strong indications that the vast majority actually don’t endorse this AL-led dispensation. Yet the non-occurrence of the much anticipated, and much expected to some extent, rising of the masses sends some very important messages crucial to be analysed and understood with some exactitude, what democracy essentially means for the common people of the land.
The hype in the media and public discourse, recently created by the repeated rhetoric of the opposition and a section of intellectuals and media personnel, about supposed spontaneous mass rising against any undemocratic regime appears to have backfired now, putting said proponents in some awkward situations. It is important to comprehend that it’s not the conventional and unconventional political moves and maneuvers that have done the trick for the incumbent regime. Intrigue cannot negate desperation of the masses, if that is a genuine one.
After all the complex brainstorming, the simple truth which seems to surface is that the form of democracy that has been practiced for the last two decades or more, and the existing absence of democracy, hasn’t made a great deal of difference for the common people of the country. The root cause of public disinterest, in mass agitation to clamour for restoration of democracy, perhaps lies there. Democracy hasn’t failed us, our social elites collectively, and our politicians precisely, have failed the widely revered system.
A natural outcome of the failing of politics in many developing countries has been non-political interventions, sometimes with tacit public approval, until politicians reorganise and reclaim their role. We can recall the public and media euphoria when the military-backed caretaker government took over in 2007. Such models were almost an established cycle of national political courses for these countries. In some countries, including recent Bangladesh, strict constitutional provisions against non-political interference has negated much of the possibility of takeover by uniformed personnel during a crisis. It might have done good, but has paved the way for civilian governments to degenerate into despotic, totalitarian regimes. For Bangladesh, it’s perhaps too early to say that. Nevertheless, the indications aren’t much promising either.
Coming back to the core issue of public distaste for the version of Bangladeshi democracy, and lack of enthusiasm to reclaim it, it can unreservedly be said that a massive revamp is essential in our political culture so as to allow the people to feel the difference between democracy and non-democracy. It would be imprudent and unwise to suggest that the people of Bangladesh would never want democracy back. This is also true, democratic continuity has been unsettled, and the accompanying political events have cost hundreds of lives and severe economic disruptions. Who knows how much human and economic cost this poor nation will have to bear to bring back power to the people?
The variety of democracy, if you can call it that, which was in vogue until 2013, did not empower people. It did empower money and muscle, which could bring about or ensure a desired electoral result and subsequently dominate each sub-domain within the socio-political spectrum, with various forms of power, while maintaining strict allegiance to corresponding dynastic power centres. The degree of the acts of theatric pampering of the political dynasties, and ill-mannered wrangling by wasting precious long parliament hours in the house, are astounding. The only difference was the fairly impartial elections due to the caretaker government system.
A further step towards deterioration has been ensured through the abrogation of it. Yet the fact remains, that even with the caretaker government system in the recent past, and two major parties rising to power alternatively, all these failed to create any substantial impressions on the masses in favour of democracy. That’s why they are so indifferent about the fate of electoral democracy in Bangladesh, for now at least. Such absence of democracy is unimaginable in the developed world. That makes the public apathy towards democracy in Bangladesh, and for that matter, in few other developing countries, even more baffling. For Bangladesh, the situation is particularly frustrating because most of our South and South East Asian neighbours are somewhat democratic; some with certain praiseworthy political culture.
Democracy is such a mammoth percept of the epoch that it’s impossible for Bangladeshis to afford revulsion to it for long. Such aversion is neither desirable nor good for our society in the longer term. The question is: How long will it take to generate democratic desire amongst the populace to make them genuinely want it, and in what form? Would that lead to the same old practices, and subsequently to the vicious circle that we have known and hated for so long? It’s imperative to figure out the answers to these questions first, before the next endeavours towards supposed democratic progression are undertaken.