Clothes maketh a woman?

Several rather painful lessons come to the fore when the recent Shakib Al Hasan dustup incident is looked at in hindsight: A lack of sportsmanship, resorting to violence to retaliate for uncouth language, and the power of money and connections in getting the police and courts to move faster than they would for ordinary people. But the greatest lesson of all – and the most shameful – is found in the Facebook pages of the various news media, where the story generated comments that should worry us far more.

Across the social media websites of half a dozen reputed news organisations – in Bengali and English – I read hundreds of comments from readers in Bangladesh who blamed the former cricket skipper’s wife for being inappropriately dressed, flirtatious, or otherwise deserving of the teasing she received. And those were just the kindest comments, scores upon scores of other comments called for her to be abused, beaten, raped, and even killed. Granted, this may not represent the majority of people in Bangladesh, but the fact that even a cross section of the population with access to the internet has such feelings is troubling.

Many of the commenters, as I looked at their visible profiles, were physicians, businessmen, lawyers, students, and political activists of all stripes … in other words, the educated elite of society. Can we blame outsiders then, when we are stereotyped as misogynistic?

Those of us who grew up in middle-class households will hardly find such reasoning shocking. We are a people obsessed with how women dress and liberally apply terms like “behaya” and “nirlojjo” to those whose fault is no more than having an outfit that does not meet the censorious scruples of society’s self-appointed monitors of sartorial morality.

I went to school in one of Dhaka’s oldest English medium institutions, where the students were drawn largely from the upper middle classes, even there such a bizarre mentality was present and thriving amongst teachers who had no problems humiliating their pupils for imagined transgressions of the length and snugness of their outfits. In one of the more idiotic edicts of our principal – who still holds sway at the said school – there was a mandate that from the following week, skirts would no longer be allowed to be worn since they were “immoral” attire … the coeds had to change their uniforms to “shalwar kameez” in the space of a weekend to accommodate the phony morality czars (and czarinas).

Three decades removed from that telling lesson on how our society viewed women, I had hoped that the times had changed for the better, that men and women are judged more by their respective knowledge and skills rather than the shape and size of their everyday clothes. If anything, the comments on the news media’s Facebook sites assure me that not only have we not moved forward, but perhaps even taken a step or two backwards.

The proverbial icing on the cake was an op-ed from a well known and unabashedly “secular” journalist in another English daily earlier this month, where this British-educated gentleman commented on the Shakib Al Hassan incident by bemoaning disapprovingly about the “Westernised” habits of modern Bengali women. If this kind of commentary is the pinnacle of intellectual secularism, I shudder to think what intellectual fundamentalism looks like.

Does the manner of a woman’s attire reflect her knowledge or skills or professional competence? Should she be subject to violence because her clothes on a given day don’t conform to the prudish dictates of beholders? The answer to both those questions should be a vehement “no” in 2014, at least in civilised societies. The fact is that in Bangladesh the answer is, at best, ambivalent. At worst, when such questions are raised, we tend to immediately go into defensive mode and either deny the seriousness of the concerns or bring up the tried and tested tripe of how our culture/religion/heritage is the most “pro woman” of all, etc etc.

At the end of the day, such an obsession with what a woman wears is unbecoming at best, and indecent to the core. The fix lies not in government mandates but in parents and schools raising children who are respectful of the sartorial choices of their siblings, cousins, friends, and coworkers. Defining deviancy downward by accommodating the sick mentality of pathologically obsessed “eve teasers” is not the way forward to ensuring greater gender equity.

Some clothes are certainly inappropriate or in poor taste in some circumstances, but neither that lack of propriety, nor the deficiency in taste, rises half to the level of the utter immorality of blaming the victims of sexual harassment in lieu of calling into account the depravity of their perpetrators.