The recent actions of the British Education Secretary Michael Gove, and his public fallout with fellow conservative leadership pretender Theresa May, provide a microcosm of ailments in Bangladesh. A hailstorm of jingoism drowns constructive discussion in the former colony; thus, a closer inspection of the comedy of errors on the shores of the once imperial overlords better serves the purpose.
One of the hallmarks of the predominantly British-instructed English medium education in Bangladesh has been the study of British texts, particularly for English lessons. Shakespeare’s plays are a mainstay, supplemented almost exclusively by Dickens and Austen.
The forward-thinking Gove has taken his inspiration to redesign the British curriculum from this overt attempt at subliminal imperialism. While the rest of the backward world, including the Commonwealth countries, looks to expand its horizons with a broader understanding of the language and its rich literature, he has exerted isolationism by culling non-British writers from the syllabus.
Before this ludicrous authoritarianism could be properly ridiculed, before even the state opening of parliament, the news cycle had moved on to the battle between Gove and May. An alleged plot by Islamists to infiltrate schools and their governing bodies to disseminate fundamentalism that is said to have been in motion for years, came to light due to an anonymous letter that is widely thought to be a fake.
May’s ministry pounced on the opportunity to make political hay due to Gove’s culpability for allowing schools to operate without satisfactory oversight. Further, he has recklessly allowed schools to set themselves up as academies and free schools outside local authority, and free to depart from the national curriculum.
Should the problem be seen as one in which ultra-conservative religious thought is exerting influence over education, the current government can only be blamed for having compounded it by expanding faith schools, in which such an influence is undoubtedly at work through Christianity. This gross misappropriation of the increased funds made available to the Department of Education should serve as a warning to Bangladesh, which sees a rise of 12% for education in the annual budget.
In a country where the contributions of governments in this sector have historically been erroneous, thereby making education one of the chief success stories of NGOs and the private sector, things can be expected to go horribly wrong.
Gove’s solution to the latter problem is derived from the thinking that caused the former. The government will require all schools to “actively promote British values,” he says. These include democracy, rule of law, liberty, tolerance, and respect. Mislabelling such universal values as British is to dangerously practice a false, and lethal, nationalism. Improvement through education and hard work is made a mockery of by an antiquated education system that is regressing, and a broken political establishment that dictates society in its entirety, replacing the ability to make any kind of change through self-improvement with self-debasing cronyism.
The most undeserving rise to the top, to rule principled, educated citizens who have no worth in this world. Instead of this, it is better to extend the principle of separation of religion and governance to separation of religion and education, with the former not being trusted with the latter (aside from Sunday schools and their alternative versions, which should be opt-in rather than mandatory).
In Bangladesh, laws allowing equality of religion or religious freedoms are weakened by blasphemy laws (an imperial construct to spread disharmony and discontent in order to better rule with an iron hand), rendering them meaningless and spreading competitive intolerance.
If the law allows limits to be set on what is acceptable, the law effectively endorses ever-worsening dogmatism and bigotry. Treading this road irreversibly and irrevocably removes all obstacles to controlling thought, speech, and beliefs. Adopting humanism as the overriding principle, on the other hand, harbours respect and tolerance, and allows people to be in charge of their beliefs, thoughts, and destinies.
While governments seem unwilling to, and incapable of, empowering people for fear of losing control over them, the palatial temples of education need to, for empowerment with knowledge is the only purpose of their existence.
If all people are equal, as they are said to be in the eyes of the laws and gods of every land and creed, then none has the right to impose oneself or one’s thoughts on another. Educational institutions are about dispensing knowledge, not judgment or faith, and governments are about representing their people by being their servants. In the words of philosopher Roger Waters: “We don’t need no thought control.”