We don’t need no education

I’ve just been struck by a mindboggling piece of news in a vernacular daily. The incident sounded like the trailer for a horror movie. On June 11, a math teacher from a Sunamganj school gave 48 used razor blades to her students and ordered them to cut their hands and legs. The reason for this gruesome order was that the students didn’t do their homework. No student had completed their 30 sums. The school administration had said they would investigate into the incident and take proper action.

This incident leads me to point out the state of punishment in schools across Bangladesh. Our teachers usually punish their students with slaps, blows, caning with sticks and dusters, making the students hold their ears and touch their noses to the ground, imposing too much homework, and detaining students for long times in a separate room. Sometimes, teachers tell their students to stick their tongues out, chew torn pages from their copies, kneel down like a turtle, walk like a horse, etc.

We’ve also seen how madrasa students in our country are beaten up by their teachers to become “disciplined.” There have been thousands of instances of teachers punishing students in our country. When I was in grade two, one of our teachers rushed into the classroom and struck me with the broken handle of a chair, which had a nail sticking out. I tried to block the strike by raising my hand, but the nail pierced through one of my fingers. Apparently, our teacher was angered by the noise coming in from our classroom, but I was not the instigator.

That was in 1972. The recent Sunamganj incident suggests that nothing has changed in this country since I was a child. Students across the country continue to be punished and victimised by their teachers, which is a serious detriment to a proper education and the normal growth of children. The government has of course banned eleven kinds of punishments in Bangladeshi educational institutions, but the horrifying ways students are punished continues with grim impacts on the children’s psychological development.

They (teachers) believe they are doing a great service to their students by punishing them like this. They think they are helping their students become disciplined, responsible, and better students. There are of course some parents who also think along the same lines as these teachers. They think punishment will make their children better human beings in the future. I don’t understand how our teachers (and some parents) got this idea of making better humans by punishing small children.

There’s another type of punishment currently going on in schools, which is the process of victimising a particular student. When a teacher happens to develop some sort of disliking for a certain student, that student’s life is doomed. The student is demonised as a black sheep of the class, or even the school, and all possible future development for this particular student is blocked. The student loses interest in everything and becomes branded as a bad person. The teachers benefit from the school authorities by making a devil out of that student. This is an atrocious practice which our teachers are engaged in.

There are many reasons for this. The first one that pops up in my mind is that there’s absolutely no training for teachers in Bangladesh, either that or the way they are trained in grossly flawed. Secondly, the recruitment process for teachers is quite defective, as no assessment of teachers’ psychologies or family background is ever conducted. Finally, school authorities are quite immature in dealing with the development of small children.

I was in a semi-military school at the age of 12. We had a system of stern punishment and physical training. We had endured it all as we were told at the very beginning that punishment and hardship were part of the training, in order to prepare us for the military. We accepted them and were never upset about it. In six months, we had become hardened enough to endure all sorts of physical tests of endurance.

We had fantastic teachers who never complained about any of us. They never made villains out of any of us. They used to deal with us through punishment and counseling, and we still remember those teachers with fondness. But I could never forgive my second grade math teacher for making me bleed.

Having said that, simply punishing and victimising students cannot benefit the education of the country. I think the teachers have to become educated first, otherwise they should choose another profession for themselves.

I feel like reminding our teachers the infamous lines from Pink Floyd’s “Another Brick in the Wall” – “We don’t need no education/ We don’t need no thought control/ No dark sarcasm in the classroom/ Teacher, leave them kids alone/ Hey, teacher, leave the kids alone.”