A popular television program host on budget day asked me to explain all the budget complexities in a simple way, more importantly, in a way understandable by his common viewers. I was mostly talking about tax incidences. Public finance textbooks taught to me in my school days were taking command of me. I could not help it. Maybe our teachers in those days didn’t emphasise too much on public speaking or populist approaches.
However, when a village lady from Brahmanbaria’s Kashba upazila asked me: “While you are emphasising on increasing investment and creating an investment-friendly environment to create employment, don’t you think that political uncertainty will play a deciding role here?” Then and there I stood corrected. We underestimate our readers and audience so much. They are not asking us to make economics easy. They have learned to appreciate the underlying economic fundamentals too. They are asking: What do we get in exchange of what?
Where is the utility of a large public administration? What are we getting from the public utility companies? What are our regulatory bodies delivering? How will these numbers help us get into a new phase of the growth story? One could ask, with so many knowledgeable people spread all over the country, why do we believe our politicians?
I was born in a humble family in a remote sub-district in southern Bangladesh. I can’t say I have seen abject poverty, but we had to learn the tricks of managing well within limited means. I studied economics for eight years. Simple economics says: Provide breaks or incentives to those who can make the best use of them.
For the last few years, Bangladesh has been included in Goldman Sachs’s Next 11 list. JP Morgan included us in the “frontier five.” People are watching Bangladesh along with Vietnam, the Philippines, Egypt, Nigeria, and Pakistan.
In this backdrop, the budget in Bangladesh can’t be a public balance sheet analysis or an income-expenditure statement. It needs to be more. I am sorry to say, the more time goes by, the weaker our financial management or economic governance is becoming.
I am not talking about the size of the budget, the selection of growth-impacting projects or their timely implementation, higher taxes on rich people, or tax imposition on the “fattening streams” of the economy. I am talking of overall management.
While the budget document is trying to do justice to environmental concerns, you see taxes have been increased on hybrid vehicles. When tax evasion is rampant among non-traded companies, was it necessary to reduce the turnover tax? When the government is trying to become more direct in tax incidences, why is source tax dominating so much in income tax, or even value added tax.
Why not bring in more people within a lower tax slab, say 5%? Why can consultants, researchers, and economists get away by paying only 10%, withholding taxes? Why is there no final assessment? Any apartment owner in Dhaka city could have assets in excess of Tk2cr, and pay an extra 10% on his paid taxes. Why not gradually bring 25 million interest-bearing account holders paying regular source taxes under the tax net? Instead of bringing more people under the tax net, why kill the golden goose?
A few years back, I came across a list of 49 persons paying more than Tk1cr in individual income tax. With my more than two decades of active banking experience, I could not find more than one known name on the list. These were all individual importers, or civil or public contractors. There too, most of their taxes were realised as source tax.
We are still saddened to see most of our budgetary allocations going for non-developmental sectors, be it education, health, or even social safety nets. It is sickening to see that in an emerging economy like ours, larger allocations are going towards keeping an inefficient, back-dated, and increasingly politicised public administration.
It is bad to observe that despite repeated requests and suggestions, we could not impose a minimum possible accountability on our state-owned enterprises, or improve the financial administration in the large-spending ministries. Most of our regulatory body chiefs are being appointed on political considerations, hence they remain dependent on the insiders mostly playing according to the gallery, or maneuvering things to his benefit, or for his own vested group.
A 6% average GDP growth rate is not bad at all. But we need more to bring out more people out of poverty, to create more employment, and build a solid national wealth. We need respectable institutions to safeguard the interest of the common people. Growth also has side effects.
We want our public representatives to truly represent us, our dreams, and build around them. We can’t put our hands on our hearts and say we already have it. We don’t know when our leadership will subscribe to the whole truth, not the half truth.