Who will build and operate Rooppur?

Qualified and trained manpower is an essential prerequisite for the implementation of a nuclear power program. Nuclear power has some special necessities like safety, requirement of nuclear laws and regulations, strict quality assurance and control, huge capital investments, long-term commitment, nuclear fuel and waste management, application of nuclear safeguards and other international obligations, which require special considerations. Consequently, management of nuclear power projects, the enforcement of nuclear regulations, and operation and maintenance of nuclear power plants require special knowledge, experience, and skills like in no other industry.

It is natural that for a country like Bangladesh, building its first nuclear power plant will lack qualified and skilled manpower. It is possible to appoint foreign consultants and sign turn-key contracts with foreign vendors to build its first nuclear power plant, but without indigenous and skilled manpower the safety and reliability of the nuclear plant cannot be guaranteed. The authority to make policy decisions and the enforcement of nuclear safety cannot be delegated to a foreign agency.

To start off, planning for nuclear power requires a small group of highly qualified engineers trained in nuclear power technology. It may be a small group but their qualifications and experience should match those of the consultant and the vendor. Without a qualified group, it is not possible for any country to take knowledge-based policy decisions or negotiate reasonably fair contracts with any consultant or vendor. Under no circumstances should the consultant or the vendor be allowed to make decisions on behalf of the owner.

It is very important to appreciate that development of manpower for a nuclear power program requires long lead times, at least 10 years before planned start of construction of the first nuclear power plant. Initially, a small knowledgeable cell is formed to make policy decisions. The group will then be gradually enlarged to carry out the pre-project and project activities, regulatory functions and finally form the operation and the maintenance team of the first nuclear plant. The cell or the group can be formed either under the national atomic energy commission or an electric supply authority.

The importance of the pre-project group should not be undermined as they perform very important tasks including long-term energy planning, nuclear power planning, including the sizes and schedules of the proposed plants, development of the legal framework and regulatory infrastructure, pre-feasibility, and siting studies. When pre-project activities are complete, the project management team takes over to carry out the project activities which include selection of sites, preparation of feasibility studies, environmental impact assessment studies, preparation of bid documents, evaluation of bids and contract negotiations, and finally plant construction.

There is a misconception among policymakers about the qualifications and experiences of manpower needed for a nuclear power program. Many believe that any research scientist with a PhD in any branch of nuclear science is an expert on nuclear power. This is not true. Research in nuclear science and technology is completely different from building, operating, and regulating nuclear reactors. While research scientists and engineers act as think tanks for nuclear power, the construction, operation, and regulation work are done mainly by mechanical, electrical, and civil engineers with MS or specialised training in nuclear engineering.

The most intriguing problem in development of manpower is, in most cases, the lack of knowledgeable people to initiate the training program. Not many people are aware of the categories of people needed for a nuclear power program. It is therefore advisable that any country building its first nuclear power plant follow the IAEA guidebook on “Manpower Development for Nuclear Power,” as far as possible.

It should be remembered that not all trainees will be able to complete the training program. Some will drop out. So, sufficient number of engineers/scientists must be trained in the beginning to compensate for the drop-outs. Moreover, training should be a continuous process to fill vacancies created by promotion or expansion of a program.

Bangladesh is going ahead with its plans to construct two 1000MWe nuclear reactors at Rooppur with Russian technical and financial assistance. Do we have enough people for project management, nuclear regulation, and the operation and maintenance of the plant, who satisfy the qualifications and experience specified by the IAEA guidebook? The answer is “No.” Even the director-general of the IAEA, Yukiya Amano, said in an interview, “Bangladesh lacks in manpower.”

I first raised this issue at a roundtable discussion organised by the Association of BUET Alumni and The Daily Star in May 2009. I suggested the immediate recruitment and training of engineers for the Rooppur project. Five years have passed since then, but no serious effort has been made in this direction. We have lost valuable time to recruit and train the people, particularly at senior levels.

It was necessary to recruit at least a dozen engineers with experience of five to 15 years in construction and operation of conventional power plants and train them in nuclear engineering. The Bangladesh Atomic Energy Commission (BAEC) did not recruit a single engineer with similar experience. How can one expect the BAEC to construct and operate a 2000MWe nuclear power plant without any previous experience of construction of any large project?

It is possible that the BAEC had some internal or administrative problems to recruit senior and experienced engineers during the last five years. With no experience of construction, the BAEC may also not appreciate the complexity and the enormity of a nuclear power project. It has, therefore, been proposed to form a separate nuclear power corporation to build, own, and operate nuclear power reactors in Bangladesh. Unlike the BAEC, which consists mostly of research scientists, the nuclear power corporation will be manned and managed by engineers, some with experience of construction and operation of large power or industrial plants. Until the formation of the nuclear power corporation, we should go slowly with the Rooppur project while vigourously continuing with the training of manpower as per the IAEA guidelines.

Last but not least, it should be pointed out that the nuclear industry entertains only the meritorious university graduates. Recruitment must, therefore, be based on merit only and no other considerations. Only meritorious, experienced, well-trained, and dedicated groups of engineers and scientists engaged in project management, nuclear regulation, and plant operation can ensure safe, reliable, and efficient operation of nuclear power plants.