At last, after an electrifying campaign and widespread media coverage, Narendra Damodardas Modi has secured the result, leading his Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) to an election victory. Someone who upholds Hindutva as his political ideology is about to be sworn in as the next prime minister of India, which, constitutionally, pledges to remain “free” from religious considerations.
Incidentally, this is the man who held the position of chief minister when over 1,000 Muslims were killed in the Gujarat riots of 2002. Consequently, he was on America’s list of those banned from getting a visa, and shunned by Europe.
Modi is the product of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), a paramilitary Hindu group which was banned thrice – after the killing of Mahatma Gandhi in 1948, during the Indira Gandhi-imposed emergency in the 1970s, and after the destruction of the Babri mosque in 1993.
In the forecasts of a Modi victory, we noticed both euphoria and cynicism topped by confusion, or a certain amount of hypocrisy, on the part of the pundits concerned. One camp tried to justify the rise of Modi on the road to the throne of Delhi while the other side has shuffled and reshuffled arguments helplessly, failing to stop his march to the top.
For any layperson not interested in the convoluted layers of politics, the question is simple – how can a man with a past blighted with spots turn into a messiah all of a sudden?
Frustration with the Congress-led government’s corruption and failure in service delivery, plus Modi’s Gujarat model of development supported by a corporate India, have been decisive factors behind his ascent.
Curiously, protagonists of the so-called Modi-fication in and outside of India don’t want to acknowledge the indoctrination of the Indian middle class into the Hindutva ideology. Moreover, they ignored a “parallel and not-so-subtle campaign aimed at developing communal polarisation” as observed by India’s Frontline magazine.
His antagonists have generally failed to grasp the simple facts. They shifted from one point to another – his humble background, questionable role in the Gujarat riot, ethical stand, and relentless tirade over issues related to Bangladesh.
While detractors squabbled over Modi’s not so redeeming aspects, the man in question went about weaving a web using religion with superb skill. What Modi has used for political gains is nothing new or unique.
So, should Narendra Modi be blamed for his political philosophy? He is at least not a political hypocrite.
Just to refresh our minds – Babri mosque was demolished not during the tenure of Atal Behari Vajpayee’s government of BJP. Narasimha Rao, the then prime minister from the Congress Party, was aware of the plot to destroy the 16th century mosque by Hindu zealots, as subsequent investigations revealed.
The use of religion in politics is also not uncommon in the West either. US presidents take oath placing their hands on the Bible and the enthusiasm of churches about “crusader” George W Bush’s re-election is not unknown any longer. British Prime Minister David Cameron has recently claimed: “Christianity compels me to make a difference,” referring to Britain as a Christian country.
Many people lack the courage to listen to the truth, let alone speak it, because double standards are so dominant in modern politics. Secularism and fundamentalism are two such words that have varying connotations in the West and in Asia. In fact, both are wrongly defined and widely misused.
In early 2013, Western diplomats patched up with Modi as soon as the BJP moved to field him as the prime ministerial candidate. Hinduvta, like Zionism, is not a problem to them, unlike their treatment of politics of Islamic ideology.
In India, Modi’s rivals could not halt his electoral wave by using the hiding of his marital status over the years and his alleged manipulation of his caste status. Still, the Gujarat chief minister will never be able to come out of the stigma of the 2002 killing of Muslims, no matter how firmly the halo is placed over him now.
The most obvious question at the moment is: What do secularist pundits expect from him as the ruler of India?
Modi will be leading a multi-religious country which has never been able to get rid of sectarian violence, riots, and insurgencies ever since its independence in 1947. Suffice to say, he is just going to add a new dimension of Hindutva to Indian politics, historically dominated by Brahminical hegemony despite the space for democratic pluralism.
Now, with Hindu nationalism dictating terms, “secular fundamentalists” should try to explain if the constitutional pillar of India – secularism – still stands unbroken.
Where are those who more often than not see the rise of fundamentalism in Bangladesh where no communal party like BJP has ever been in power?
Secularism does not denote religious pluralism. It rather rejects religion, if we go by the dictionary. Practically, it is hard to become neutral about religion when someone is a true believer. Secularists fall short of understanding communal harmony, which should be upheld by any civilised nation.