Our elite law enforcement force Rapid Action Battalion’s alleged involvement in the recent murders in Narayanganj has certainly come as a blow to people’s trust in law enforcement personnel. Our understanding is that our lives will be much more difficult from now on, as there are thousands of anti-citizen elements spread across the country, sneakily looking for an opportunity to harm us. If RAB involvement turns out to be true, the people will lose the last shred trust on the law enforcers.
As we know, RAB’s mission is to “prevent crime, terrorism, and apprehend criminals.” Since its initiation on April 14, 2004, it has been successful in running thousands of anti-crime operations. To our mind, RAB works much in the manner of American Homeland Security, as the members of RAB have successfully played various roles in Bangladesh’s internal security. They have helped recover a huge number of unauthorised arms, ammunitions, explosives, and similar weapons.
They have stopped and apprehended many armed gangs of criminals. They have assisted the police force and other agencies to maintain law and order. They have quite a big intelligence gathering operation which is used in crime prevention. They have also carried out special duties that the government has assigned them wherever there was a need.
On the other hand, as a force, RAB has also been criticised at home and abroad, time and again, for their alleged involvement in extra-judicial killings. Yes, they have been successful in weeding out hundreds of vicious criminals who have been harming the people in various ways. However, it’s also true that those fallen criminals were a tip of the iceberg – they were mere pawns who were created by bigger criminals who usually don’t come to fore.
RAB has quelled the pawns, but they have left the silent ring leaders. Apart from this disappointment, RAB, unlike the police, has always enjoyed public trust on them.
Now, if we look at the police force, they are a ubiquitous bunch, but it would be really difficult to single out one Bangladeshi who really has any trust on them. As citizens, we have seen the members of the police, apart from a very few, getting involved in crimes themselves. They have proven to be a team known as “extortionists.” It’s anybody’s knowledge that when there’s a political crisis, they would engage in an “extortion business.” It’s very difficult to get service from the police force without making them “happy.”
If you look at the traffic police, it seems that their main purpose is to earn money from the CNG-wallahs, motorcyclists, bus drivers, street vendors, and to a great extent rickshaw-wallahs. Despite many instructions from the ministry to remove unfit vehicles from the streets, they can still ply on simply because the police personnel want to earn illegal money. But surprisingly, the Bangladesh Police website says about its mission: “To provide quality service by competent, efficient, and dedicated professionals enjoying trust and respect of citizens to make Bangladesh a better and safer place to live.” What a waste of some valuable words!
The aspect of unfriendly attitude of the police force has been discussed, perhaps hundreds of times, in several – both at the government as well as non-government – levels. However, very little has changed. I believe the entire police force is run with a basic strategic flaw. During the monarchy and British-India days, the kings and colonisers had used the police force against the citizens. The nature of policing in British-India and in Britain, during the British Raj, was quite different. The police force in British-India was very different from that of England. The police was used as a repressive tool for the repressors.
Unfortunately, we, in an independent country, have miserably failed to realise that we are really independent. The administration in Bangladesh, for that matter in the entire South Asia, is still using its law enforcers against the people. The law enforcers should be the enemies of the criminals, not of the common people who actually most of the times need help from them.
We, however, shouldn’t put all the blame on the law enforcers. History says they haven’t been used as “service providers of the people” by the state. As commoners we believe, the lawmakers would formulate the laws, and the law enforcers would uphold those laws. There have been allegations against the lawmakers for using law enforcers as political tools for their own partisan gains. This attitude has, in fact, not allowed the law enforcing agencies to grow and become protectors of the citizens.
But time has come to change this. It would be a disaster if we lose faith on our law upholders. We want to depend on them.