A bank robbery captured headlines, incumbents amassed vast wealth, gold smuggling appears to be a regular trade, sale of adulterated foods is still rampant, rural hospital patients remain unattended, public exam question papers are leaked, tenders are manipulated, and violence dominates campuses. Surpassing all of this, human life has become cheaper as we can tell from the recent spate of abductions and killing of people. Meanwhile, the killing of Bangladeshis along the border has not come to a halt.
“Where is the government?” cries a newspaper editorial. Obviously by default, we have a government which has shown its authority by suppressing the rights and views of everyone else. So why should we bother about a few signs of governance failure, especially when these may be the result of excesses allegedly indulged in by the most powerful elements within the government or the ones associated with the ruling party?
However, for a man who hasn’t completely discarded his ethics, it is not easy to comprehend the reasons behind the misuse of power by rulers or their desperation to cling to that power by force. While in power, a ruler can censor criticism and even annihilate potential adversaries. Also, a tyrant can display sadistic joy in sitting on the body of a victim or even by desecrating the deceased. Yet, even the most powerful ruler can’t control the public from talking about the state of their governance.
I asked a senior friend, aligned with the Awami League, about the justification of holding power without public support. “This government would correct many anomalies and take a lot of populist steps,” he said. Sheikh Hasina’s government, constrained by a shortage of revenue and sluggish investments, will try to accomplish what the president of the most powerful country often fails to do – convince the people. That too, with serious democratic deficiencies and so much burden of backers and beneficiaries.
The government covertly boasts of backing from an influential external power, believing it to be enough to keep its rule unchallenged. What a way of building self-confidence in national politics, that too without the people’s involvement.
Widening alienation of our “dominant minority” — the ruling class — from moral values, social norms, and political ideals has left the country unguarded and the citizens helpless. In a reign of injustice, too much compromise with immoral acts all around has metamorphosed many so-called “good people” into virtual cowards.
Frustrated, restless, and rapacious, society becomes sullied while the elite seem resigned to the situation. Opportunists question why the naïve ones are so obsessed with the righteousness of actions in “realpolitik” – the world has never been just. Cunning people are often short-sighted, forgetting that wrongdoers have never been spared either. We are witness to the downfall of a number of powerful rulers of the 20th century.
Ferdinand Marcos of the Philippines, General Augusto Pinochet of Chile, Saddam Hussain of Iraq, and Muammar al-Gaddafi of Libya (don’t forget HM Ershad!) ruled their countries for a long period, but history terms them simply as autocrats. Despite being elected twice, George W Bush has been ranked as one of the worst presidents of the United States for his wrong-headed policies.
Babrak Karmal and Dr Najibullah of Afghanistan became presidents with Soviet intervention and they were treated as traitors by the Afghans. Lhendup Dorji, the chief minister of Sikkim during its merger with India, is widely referred to as a symbol of betrayal in his motherland.
Apartheid South African rulers had kept Nelson Mandela in jail for 27 years but could not change his destiny as one of the best statesmen of his time. Israel’s Ariel Sharon had confronted Palestine leader Yasser Arafat both in the battlefield and in politics, but the former was despised for his hawkish policy and the latter was loved worldwide for his cause.
Nawab Sirajuddoula’s army chief Mir Zafar Ali Khan was successful in ensuring the former’s defeat in the battle of Plassey by collaborating with the East India Company, only to emerge as a permanent betrayer in history.
Nisar Ali Titumir proved his mad love for his motherland by fighting from a “fort made of bamboo” against a far superior colonial army, embracing martyrdom in the end. Despite fighting a losing battle, Titumir is considered a hero. It is actually a matter of choice of a politician whether she/he wants to be nondito or nindito, Bangla words that sound similar but bear opposite meanings – “celebrated” and “condemned” respectively.
Sheikh Hasina’s AL government will be remembered for the share market crashing twice, the Padma Bridge corruption case, the swindling of bank money (Hall-Mark and other scams), patronisation of godfathers, the BDR rebellion that resulted in so many unnecessary deaths, presidential clemency to murderers, the Sagor-Runi killing, politicisation of public institutions, late-night crackdown on Hefazat-e-Islam, a farcical election held to stay in power, extra-judicial killings, and political persecution.
What else does the AL leadership, super-conscious of history, aim to add to the list before calling it a day?