Is it climate change?

I have been conducting research on climate change adaptation of multinational corporations over the last three years. As a part of my research, I interviewed research participants from the government, NGOs, and certain private sectors in Bangladesh.

At one point of the interview process, one of my interviewees started interviewing me regarding my understanding of climate change impacts in Bangladesh rather than answering my questions. I felt my interviewee’s disrespect toward me regarding my understanding of the subject while I was exploring the adaptation to those so-called impacts. My analytical interviewee provided me with an important perspective, saying:

“Nowadays, everyone is jumping on the climate change bandwagon … I am not a sceptic but we are following a dangerous path of convicting others while totally ignoring our own duties. Take for example the infrastructure development, which turned natural hazards into disasters. A few years ago, we linked our drought, flood, salinity to India’s unilateral withdrawal of water at Farakka Barrage, but now those things are linked to climate change as if Farakka Barrage does not exist anymore and India does not have any role in making our climate change adaptation more difficult.”

His disrespect had resulted from the understanding that I was one of those who had jumped on the “climate change bandwagon” and started to conduct a climate change adaptation research without understanding the main reasons behind the impacts. I convinced my interviewee that one of my goals is to gather alternative perspectives through my research which interviewees like him could provide. I had earned back his respect.

As I observe, climate change and its impacts have extensively been discussed in Bangladesh over the last six years. Release of the fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and subsequently the 13th Conference of Parties in 2007, provided the momentum to that extensive discussion. Since then, there has been a growing tendency in Bangladesh to link natural hazards like flood, drought, and saline water intrusion to climate change because of rainfall anomalies, increased temperature, and the rising sea level.

However, it was previously widely discussed and agreed in Bangladesh that unilateral and arbitrary withdrawal and release of Ganges water by India at the Farakka Barrage are to blame for the sudden and massive floods, drought, and increased salinity in Bangladesh. Therefore, when climate change suddenly overshadows the existence of Farakka Barrage, or how India tries to control the rivers upstream, people like my interviewee become curious about the intentions of those who do not highlight the role of upper riparian countries behind the natural hazards in Bangladesh.        

While Bangladesh is termed as one of the most vulnerable countries due to climate change at the moment, we observe that the normative discussion highlights the historical and future responsibilities of developed and advanced developing countries in changing the climate. Along with climate change adaptation at different levels, it is generally argued that high-emitting countries should reduce their greenhouse gas emissions to keep climate change adaptation feasible and manageable for countries like Bangladesh.

However, as we can see from Bangladesh’s experience, such a common argument often under emphasises the responsibility of upper riparian countries like India when their self-interested trans-boundary river management further fuels natural hazards in low riparian countries like Bangladesh that are already affected by climate change impacts. Ironically, the interests of India are often linked to their country-specific climate change adaptation process. Due to this paradox, existing trans-boundary river management may be conducive to national climate change adaptation of India and not to regional climate change adaptation, which includes Bangladesh.

I have found that critical uncertainty has been evolved in terms of functional climate change adaptation due to faulty attribution of all natural hazards to climate change while ignoring some other significant reasons. However, I think such a faulty attribution by the Bangladeshi government or any other group and any related relief of the Indian government would be unsustainable in the long run. Based on the predictions and opinions of experts, it could be argued that India’s stability would be challenged due to the adverse impacts of both climate change and trans-boundary river management in Bangladesh.

Therefore, in Bangladesh, whenever we face intense natural hazards, we need to ask the question – “climate change or not?” – to explore the reasons behind the hazards. The government of Bangladesh must acknowledge the importance of the shared water of Ganges and other rivers on social, political, environmental, and economic conditions of the country and pursue a regional climate change adaptation approach with support from India.

This regional climate change adaptation approach should integrate concerns related to both trans-boundary river management and climate change and leave no room for ambiguity. Through this regional approach, the governments of both Bangladesh and India can ensure effective adaptation to climate change as well as a conflict-free and secure South Asia.