The age of self-determination

Being childless and prone to debauchery and fast cars on broken streets are signs of a mid-life crisis, as are being directionless and clueless. Celebrations on the day of birth can be even more raucous at such times. The eve of a birthday, however, allows time for reflection and quiet contemplation.

There is no end of problems in a country turning 43. Much of it is covered in every media outlet and at every dinner table on a daily basis for 363 days a year, 364 on each leap year. Even International Language Day, the Bengali New Year, and the two Eids are not spared a few sneering, judgmental words, mostly lamenting the erosion of tradition.

Independence Day and Victory Day are the only exceptions, the biannual conventions of positive words painting scenic landscapes of a utopian future once the immense dormant potential of Bangladesh is fulfilled.

Finally. The observations have not changed much over the years, mirroring the lack of deviation in the news – corruption, crime, perverse politics, an eternal blame game, hypocrisy – from one average day to another. Golden Bengal, eternal hope, dreams of the forefathers, development statistics, and more will be paraded today.

For one day, all ills will be forgotten. It will sound like Bangladesh is the best country in the world. The belief with which the resilient people can truthfully say that is fading fast. This loss of faith needs to be arrested. Bangladesh is not the best country in the world, but it can be. It needs to succeed.

It is a nation that was birthed by a sacred tenet of international law that is regularly under threat. The right to self-determination was exercised successfully, although, in keeping with the trend to reject it, much of the world sought to deny it. The naysayers, for geopolitical reasons that always outweigh humanity, justice, and human rights, included the US during the Liberation War, and China for many years after.

The former, the defenders of human rights and present-day imperialists, can never decide where it stands on the issue, despite mostly refusing it outside of Cold War politics, while the latter has allowed pleas from Tibet and Taiwan to fall on deaf ears.

The situation in Ukraine aside, Scotland’s upcoming referendum on independence, the loud dissenting Basque and Catalan voices, the state of Puerto Rico, the Falkland Islands and Quebec, the plight of the Kurds and the Naga people, and the ongoing problems in Pakistan, including Baluchistan and Kashmir, show how this venerable and vulnerable doctrine is as relevant as ever.

The three countries Bangladesh is most often compared to or made to aspire to by its educated class – the USA, India, and Pakistan – had disparate journeys in their first 43 years.

The US, already in existence for nearly two centuries and a superpower by the time Bangladesh came into being, added 11 states to the original 13, enumerated freedoms by ratifying the Bill of Rights, and strengthened its system of governance by passing twelve distinct constitutional amendments.

A democratic India implemented a functioning bicameral parliament, conducted its first nuclear test, and moved steadily towards becoming a superpower despite taking part in multiple wars, having a head of government assassinated and instituting dynastic politics.

Pakistan fared worse, affected by the same plights. There were only two general elections that saw the formation of democratically elected governments and three different versions of the constitution, with states of emergency, declarations of martial law, and military dictators being the accepted political system.

The self-determination that led to the independence of those three countries, however, was the variety that was practised in the twilight of imperialism, when empires were forced to grant colonies their independence. The postcolonial broadening of the definition, with the principle being established as an undeniable right of “all peoples” to determine their own political, economic, social, and cultural statuses, has seen it extended to cases of a state oppressing its people, discriminating against them, and violating their human rights.

The precedent, asserted by Bangladesh, became that independence was legally possible under such circumstances. The sanctity of people’s rights, thus, demands that this country succeeds.

Above all else, Bangladesh is able to hold its head high as an independent country because of the will of its people. The introspection reveals that its success, and the championing of the fundamental right that saw it born, remain wholly reliant on the determination of its people – the entire population, not merely the self-appointed handful that seek to control it.