Developing a defense

When we talk about security, we are focusing on three aspects: People, investments, and assets.

The security of people includes people working in a particular territory or district, working at a particular location for a particular employer, and also people travelling from other locations to live and work in a certain locality for a certain reason.

The security of investments ensures the laws of the land while maintaining the environment of conducting business and determining the ease or difficulty of doing business in a particular area.

The security of assets protects both physical, information-based assets and knowledge-based assets, where asset value is determined by material and emotional utility -- while helping to retain and improve the confidence of the communities, government, and entrepreneurs.

The dimensions of governance include the governing of people, business, and social activities. Governing people means educating people on law and order, implementing the same law and order upon them -- partially, diligently, and consistently while allocating resources to perform this governance effectively.

The governance of business activities ensures consistency, which impacts security of investment and assets, and as a result fosters competition, encourages entrepreneurship, and rewards investors in legitimate ways.

Development broadly covers the area of human development such as education, heath, and access to opportunities. Development of skills for jobs, readiness for conducting economic transactions, and use of automation in everyday life also falls within the boundary of development. It also oversees the progress in economic parameters and decides whether progress is sustainable.

Development and security: How are they linked?

Security and development are closely linked. Administrative efforts are important to ensure security, but it is the development that is the strongest and most effective security blanket that makes the population a part of the system, a strong stake-holder in ensuring that effort to change the system is gradual and not disruptive.

Administrative efforts are important to ensure security, but it is the development that is the strongest and most effective security blanket

The UN admits there can be no development without security and no security without development, and both depend on respect for human rights and rules of law. In this regard, the vicious cycle is a lack of development leading to conflict leading to a lack of development.

Researchers in Nigeria identified food sufficiency, water supply, power supply, good roads, good schools, good hospitals, functional infrastructure, decent housing, effective public transportation system, etc as genuine indicators for national security. It can be seen that countries that record high levels of terrorism tend to be under-developed though development indicators do not significantly correlate with levels of terrorism globally.

The above puts a lot of weight on “development.” The age old debate about growth vs distribution becomes almost invalid, as without inclusive growth the aspiration or effectiveness of development is almost nil.

State fragility, radicalism, and militancy in the region

During the last decade and so, the world has observed a steady rise in terrorism and radicalism. Many fragile states have lost law and order and have fallen into chaos. Terrorist organisations such as IS and al-Qaeda have used the Islamic faith to persuade and bring more people to their cause and to execute their ruthless acts.

The primary cause of terrorism is the religious conflict instigated by these organisations. But their beliefs are founded on a ridiculous misunderstanding of Islamic teachings. Statistics show a lot of people in countries such as Malaysia, Pakistan, and Nigeria have shown support for IS while the majority was hesitant to pick sides.

IS has so far been successful in its attempt to recruit more people by spreading its radical beliefs. Several attacks have been carried out by militants during the past year, resulting in massive casualties. There have been shootings all over Europe, bombing and shooting in many Asian countries, and the most recent of such events is the targeted killing in the diplomatic zone of Dhaka.   

Impact of terrorism on development

The global economic impact of violence was $13.6 trillion PPP in 2015. This figure is equivalent to 13.3% of world GDP or $1,876 PPP for every person in the world, approximately 11 times the size of global FDI, which was $1.23 trillion in 2014. The direct cost of violence in 2015 is 30 times the amount spent on official development assistance (ODA) in 2014. A 10% decrease in the economic impact of violence would produce a peace dividend of $1.36 trillion PPP.

How to fight terrorism

Contrary to popular belief, leaders of IS and other terrorist organisations are often highly educated. The recent Dhaka attack shows people from educated backgrounds being radicalised. So, taking this prospect into consideration, meaningful education against violence might be the answer. Spreading the idea of meaningful change will strengthen the fight against radicalism.

Technology proves to be a double-edged sword in the fight against terrorism. Communication and propaganda spread via the internet.

A brilliant example of this is IS’s Dabiq magazine. Although through better understanding of technology by law enforcement agencies, tracking criminals can become possible and much easier. Through better surveillance, security can be assured.

Promoting security is a substantial part of societal progress. There is a need to ensure a clear separation between military and humanitarian actors in line with the core principals of humanitarian action, particularly neutrality and independence.

However, the importance in some instances of civil-military co-operation in the pursuit of security and development remains. A comprehensive approach to international and national security must transcend the traditional emphasis on military power and armed competition.

The game of prioritisation

While the idea of justice and governance is quite extensively debated and established in both Western and Eastern philosophies, it is generally perceived very cynically nowadays. They think that the establishment tries to make them believe it is a moral issue, while, in effect, actually defines it as a tool for the privileged to protect their accumulated privileges.

The level of governance standard in any state/society strongly depends upon the critical mass that is available in that sphere, and any external/exogenous effort to improve that becomes not only futile, but many times leads to the strengthening perception that the system is grossly rigged. Prioritising governance can sometimes impact local businesses in a negative manner

Forced security measures might establish fear of law instead of respect for law. Prioritising on security and governance raises some concerns regarding development. Areas of the country needing immediate attention might be de-prioritised due to increased resource-utilisation in security measures. Lack of government measures regarding the flood in the southern region of the country is an example of this.

Another concern is the focus on higher security. Increased security and surveillance can blur the line between a secured state and a police state. Unchecked power of law enforcement agencies is likely to result in abuse and harassment of the general people. Though security is a global concern, it affects third world countries more as it may de-prioritise governance and development.

Megatrends

Technological advancements are going to create enormous opportunities. The seven most impactful technologies of the coming future can be artificial intelligence, augmented reality, block-chain, drones, robots, virtual reality, and 3D printing. This new industrial revolution is going to change how we make and sell products, as well as how we buy and use products of the future.

Rapid urbanisation has resulted in one-and-a-half million people becoming part of urban population every week. The world population is rising by 145 every minute. At the present rate, we will be burning all fossil fuels in another half a century.

We can agree that development is required to ensure security, but how to ensure inclusive growth quickly is the big question for which I really do not have any answer. This is indeed a worrisome matter.

Looking at history, we will see that unique situations were rectified by the emergence of new generations. The truth is evident from the fall of the Roman republic, Arabia pre and post-Muhammad (pbuh), the renaissance in medieval Europe, and then in the case of Europe before and after both the World Wars.

This is a grim perspective. It will be difficult for all of us to accept the new order from the generation change. It can be suspected that the security issue will continue to trouble us and the policy prescription will tend to put more emphasis on administrative efforts rather than development initiatives.

There is no ready-made policy directive to solve this problem. One thing is clear: We need to speed up the inclusive growth process. For that, the governance process needs to be far more simplistic and nimble, and at the same time transparent and credible. Although, how such a model can he achieved is not yet certain.

Mamun Rashid is a banker, economic analyst, and educationist. The article is the excerpt of a keynote paper presented at a seminar by Centre for Governance Studies.