A law for the workers

Corporate manslaughter is a crime which makes it possible for a corporation to be punished for conduct that leads to a person’s death. The offence is recognised in the UK, Australia, Hong Kong, and some other countries. But not here. In Bangladesh, we never practiced such a law.

After the Tazreen factory fire, several investigation reports, including the Home Ministry’s, has recommended that legal action be taken against the factory owner. We have no doubt that our existing criminal law is enough to bring factory-owners to justice. But the problem lies elsewhere. Laws which can enforce justice definitely exist, but simultaneously, a culture of impunity exists as well between garment owners and workers.

The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007 is a landmark law. For the first time, companies and organisations can be found guilty of corporate manslaughter as a result of serious management failures. But in our country, we did all these by CrPC, and failed to get justice.

If we go through our criminal justice system which focuses on the Penal Code 1860, the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, we find that ensuring exemplary punishment for a person liable for corporate manslaughter is almost impossible, because the offences defined in the penal code do not describe corporate manslaughter and provisions relating to homicide, but are mainly based on direct physical overt acts.

When we force workers to enter garment factories in a vulnerable building like Rana Plaza, is it not criminal negligence? When we locked the gates of Tazreen Garments, killing workers, how can we call this just an accident?

Bangladesh needs recognition of corporate manslaughter, and transformation of the offence into a legal framework, because there are some loopholes in our existing laws. The Labour Act 2006 is the main law relating to the safety and security of labour in Bangladesh. The code is based on the preventive theory of jurisprudence, and the theory is not applicable when a person is already dead from a fire.

The Labour Act takes into account both civil and criminal liability. If it is accepted as a civil matter, the issue is therapy by compensation. In certain cases, it is remedied by punishment according to criminal proceedings.

The Labour Act 2006 takes care of proceedings on behalf of the dead. But most of the time, they do not get proper compensation. Now, the High Court is trying to set up a committee that will work towards a proper compensation strategy, and how it can be implemented.

Most of the time, we see that when the government has to pay financial aid to the family or the BGMEA, it gives charity to the family of dead and wounded workers. If corporate manslaughter is accepted, the government will get a handsome fine from the corporation that is liable for deaths. If normal rules of criminal liability are followed, it will be difficult to establish the liability of large companies.

According to a preliminary report from a government inquiry, a 214-page report to the Home Ministry was submitted, blaming the Tazreen factory owner for negligence, claiming that nine of his mid-level managers and supervisors prevented employees from leaving their stations even after the fire alarm went off. Experts say we need manslaughter laws to identify all criminals for the sake of workers.

The report stated: “It is clear that the unsafe nature of this factory, and the actions taken by management once the fire started, were the primary suppliers to the dreadful death toll.”

In 1990, 32 workers were killed in a stampede when a fire broke out at Saraka Garments in Mirpur. Since then, fire accidents in garment factories have killed more workers. In 2012, we saw the worst factory fire in the history of the garments industry in Bangladesh at Tazreen Fashions.

This law exists in different countries around the world. Canada, Australia, Norway, Finland, and Denmark have already incorporated these laws under their penal codes. In this subcontinent, this law does not exist yet, but if introduced, it might be a good step forward for workers’ rights.