Partnering for health

Since the 1990s, an ideological growth has been witnessed – that public and private sectors should work together. International bodies constantly advocate for public-private partnerships (PPPs) as the policy innovation of recent times and actively lobbying to have partnerships be accepted as the way forward.

Although the dynamics of public-private partnership arrangements are generic across social and health sectors, international literature has been persistently emphasising on country-specific studies on partnership to gain more insights, to know more about its effectiveness, and to mitigate the challenges of partnership to ensure safe and efficient health service delivery.

Recently, I have browsed through a number of literatures where people have made claims about the relative sizes of the public and private sectors in healthcare delivery. A report on the private sector in Africa by World Bank claims that the private health sector now provides half of all health services in the region. A few documents reviewed recently claimed that “much” of medical care is provided by the private sector – an endorsement popularly highlighted in mass media.

The government of Bangladesh has been pushing for public-private partnerships in health service delivery since the 1980s. The healthcare system of Bangladesh is a mix of public and private initiatives.

In terms of physical infrastructure, the public sector is stronger than the private sector, although in terms of coverage, the healthcare system of the country should be termed a privatised one. Although public health services attempt to make healthcare accessible and affordable for the poor and marginalised, it has largely failed to do so.

On the other hand, high out-of-pocket expenditure and the unpredictable quality of care by the private sector has limited access to health services for the poor. NGOs have emerged as an effective option to make health services accessible to the poor, sometimes in a vertical program, sometimes in collaboration with the government.

To improve efficiency in the use of public funds and broaden coverage of health services through utilising the potentials of all the providers available, the government has opted for public-private partnership.

In the health sector, public-private partnership has taken a variety of forms, producing diverse results. In the present experiences of two programs, one has been successful and the other is challenging. As a successful program, the Expanded Program of Immunisation (EPI) has been selected while National Nutrition Program (NNP) has been picked up as a challenging model.

Based on the performance of the programs in terms of coverage and access to services, the immunisation program has been termed as successful, and the nutrition program as challenging.

This finding is from a study sponsored by the James P Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University. Data for the study was collected through documentary surveys and interviewing key government and NGO officials of the respective programs.

It is a continuing challenge for the health sector to find optimal means for harnessing the strengths of all the sectors in ways which will best address priority needs.

Learning lessons from the existing partnerships is the simple and most straightforward means of identifying the best opportunities, and steer clear of the weaknesses. The present study offers two sets of findings: Factors that contribute to the success of partnership, and factors that contribute to make partnerships difficult and challenging.

Public-private partnerships are increasingly advocated to alleviate deficiencies in the public health system, as well as to reduce economic stress on those who seek services from an expensive, burgeoning, and unregulated private health sector.

Focusing on Bangladesh, it is imperative to observe and assess how the private sector is tapped to deliver health care services to poor and underserved sections of society through collaborative arrangements with the government.

Having emerged as a key reform initiative, aspects of public-private partnership can be examined to understand the genesis of private sector partnerships, the ways in which the private sector is encouraged to deliver public health services, and the models and formats that make such partnerships possible.

It is important to analyse challenges, opportunities, and benefits of implementing public-private partnerships, and to explore whether partnerships with the private sector can be designed to deliver healthcare services to the poor.