I will not choose

Politics is about making choices. Making choices does not necessitate choosing sides but choosing ideas and ideals. It is about compromise and being constructive. About being partisan on issues but not dogmatic to a party or a narrative. Why must we choose sides if neither of the big parties, nor the myriad of the smaller ones, represent our ideals, interests, or elicit our sympathy?

In an article published by this paper some time ago, there was a call for people to essentially ascribe blame for the recent violence and turmoil to the BNP and Jamaat and exonerate the ruling party of blame – to a greater degree – because they were on the “winning side.”

It is this sort of hyper-nationalism that is perhaps the root of the problem in many ways. It posits an “us or them” narrative, which resonates very well to the terror theme that has been developed in an attempt to stir feelings of righteous indignation by providing partial facts.

The casual relation that ties A with B, BNP and terrorism, is dangerous and pretty weak. Dangerous because it tries to drum up a moral case to support one party over the other – something done repeatedly in that article – and condemns the reader for making an immoral choice if it does not confer with the author’s point of view.

Would a case of highlighting the weakness of the government on issues of law and order not have been more apt? Weak, well like all neo-con fear-mongering evoked by the repeated use of terror without a systemic or rigorous, but lazy, analysis.

It is the cheap, crass ploy to divide that is the problem with politics, creating a partisan politics that has no space for healing but based on hollow rhetoric entwined with morality of the nationalist-fascist bend.

Terror, terrorism, and terrorists are useful words to hide behind when one wishes to project a sense of urgency, the need for unity when public opinion is low and the need to polarise, demonise is high.

The violence currently conducted by all sides – including state actors and sanctioned groups – is abhorrent and needs to be condemned. Attacks on civilians are never justified. They are violent, criminal acts whose perpetrators need to be brought to justice.

It is the crude understanding of politics as a zero-sum game that has put us in the situation we are in today. It is the cheap nationalist feelings stirred up to be manipulated by all sides that has led to such entrenched positions. Instead of choosing sides, why not choose ideals?

Togetherness, forgiveness, and honesty? Maybe that is too idealistic but something with the emphasis on being inclusive and not beating down the ever popular, and easy “us and them” rhetoric would be helpful, useful in such a situation. It is easy to divide, perhaps far too easy, but inclusiveness is what is missing and needed.

Such a call, of course, could not exist in the narrative that says Jamaat and, by association, the BNP and their followers are “terrorists” to whom we cannot be held “hostage.” In that equation, would the AL not also be terrorists for their joint anti-government programs in the mid-90s?

Less people died during that period – to their credit – but to claim that those were “pro-poor” would be a stretch. Pro-democracy, yes, but like these, they were neither free nor fair.

Those of us who refuse to take sides in this ongoing saga are – or at least I am – not able to identify with the narratives propagated by either side. Maybe it is that we choose not to take sides as the way you would have us; a bland monochrome where for the sake of being partisan we let go of the greys (the complex and complicated history and facts) and join a party.

Sorry, but that is not going to happen, not because I will join the BNP or Jamaat. Being neutral is not the same as not choosing, it means that I do not wish to hoist a banner of blades of rice, a boat, or whatever the JaPa or Jamaat insignia is.

Instead, I’d like to see a politics based on basic ideas of justice – for all and not just the victor. A politics based on egalitarian values of respect, and equality regardless of wealth, and political and social connections. A politics where the dogmatism, if it must remain, is to uphold the value of human life, dignity, and rights. Above all a politics based on unity and dialogue.

Any government that comes into power – wherever – is not only ruling over their cadres and supporters. Their duty is towards the “jonogon,” a word that is being misused in the public arena to such an extent that it holds almost no meaning. It is in the interest of their supporters and detractors that governments need to rule, and that is something that we are yet to see since the democratic transition (sic) of 1991.

Does this sound far too optimistic?

Well, why not? Why not start with outlandish ideals and try to work as close to that as possible? Despite years of gross misconduct and mismanagement, the country has managed to elevate itself and millions of people from where they were 20 or 30 years ago.

This, along with countless other achievements, is not celebrated in the manner it should be – an all important character is oft missing from such narratives. The people’s tenacity has led to such development regardless of what has been happening in the country. It is their fortitude, perseverance, and resourcefulness that is left out when it needs to be celebrated and embraced.

For development programs to work, it is not only the management or the planning that is working, but also people’s reactions to it. They will embrace it and continue along the path of self and communal improvement.

I will keep rejecting all the parties until there is a change in the way business is done. Until the people – all citizens – are protected, given dignity, and their interests are prioritised, not only in rhetoric but through action. This, I believe, can only happen through a new beginning, one where new spaces with fresh voices flourish, and move Bangladeshi politics into a post-1971 era.