Avoiding constitutional face-off

Our constitution is the solemn expression of the will of the people of Bangladesh. It is the supreme law of this land. If any law is inconsistent with this constitution, that other law shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be void. This constitution is our pride, most beloved and respected since we achieved this after a nine-month War of Independence in 1971.

Politics with this constitution is not something new in Bangladesh. Defamation of the constitution, misuse of constitutional power, and violations of the constitution are very popular means of blame games. Political parties who secure two-thirds majority in the parliament are entitled to bring any amendment to the constitution.

Such provisions are not prima facie dreadful, but in a country like ours where politicians lack basic humanitarian attributes, such power can be lethal for the nation. The Constitution of the United States went through 27 amendments in the 238 years of it existence, and no amendment has been made in the last 22 years, whereas we have already made 15 amendments in the 43 years since independence. I am not against the frequent rate of amendments, but am concerned with the idea of treating our beloved constitution as a weapon or shield to safeguard one’s political agenda.   

Recently, another controversy ignited with the oath-taking ceremony of 292 newly elected parliament members. On January 9, the speaker administrated the oaths of the newly elected members of the 10th National Parliament. The members of the ninth parliament are also there since it is not yet dissolved.

Therefore, right now we have more than 600 MPs in a parliament of 350 seats. The situation is surprising, but true. President Abdul Hamid invited the parliament leader to form a new government on January 12. The BNP is terming such oath-taking ceremony and formation of government as a violation of the constitution, and the Awami League claims such actions are in consistency with the constitution.

Before I put forward my opinion, I would like to mention a few relevant provisions of the constitution. Article 123(3) of the constitution says: “A general election of the members of Parliament shall be held - (a) in the case of a dissolution by reason of the expiration of its term, within the period of ninety days preceding such dissolution; and (b) in the case of a dissolution otherwise than by reason of such expiration, within ninety days after such dissolution. Provided that the persons elected at a general election under sub-clause (a) shall not assume office as members of Parliament except after the expiration of the term referred to therein.”

Article 148(2A) says: “If, within three days next after publication through official Gazette of the result of a general election of members of Parliament under clause (3) of article 123, the person specified under the constitution for the purpose or such other person designated by that person for the purpose, is unable to, or does not, administer oath to the newly elected members of Parliament, on any account, the Chief Election Commissioner shall administer such oath within three days next thereafter, as if, he is the person specified under the constitution for the purpose.”

From the plain reading of Article 123, it appears that taking oath and forming government before the dissolution of the ninth national parliament on January 25 is unconstitutional. On the other hand, if we read Article 148, we understand that it is now a constitutional obligation to administer oath, since the official gazette of the election result was published. Therefore, I will term this predicament as a “face-off between constitutional provisions.”

In this particular complex scenario, both the articles of the constitution are applicable, and the same are defiance and compliance of the constitution at the same time. Now, a few questions can arise, like how this complexity kicked off, who is responsible for this, and how it can be cured.

The answers to the questions are all inter-related. First of all, the election could have been held a few days later, like just before January 24, in order to avoid the confusion. Or it could have been held under Article 123(3)(b), ie within 90 days after dissolution of the ninth parliament.

On the other hand, the Election Commission could have avoided the controversy by publishing the gazette of the election result after a few days, as there is no legal bar for them to do that. If the gazette is published on January 23 or 24, and the oath takes place on January 25, all the activities would have been in consistency with the constitution. Without keeping this in mind, the Election Commission hastily published the gazette, and the government is left with no option but to violate an article of the constitution to comply with another of the same.

In a concluding remark, I would say that in one sense, the oath-taking by newly elected members is legal, but will remain debatable always. The newly elected should refrain from forming a cabinet until January 25 to remedy the present controversy a little. In the future, both the government and the Election Commission should do their homework cautiously on constitutional provisions regarding the holding of general elections to avoid a constitutional face-off.