Does society need the death penalty? It is the million dollar question now, as voices in favour of certain universal human rights are getting stronger day by day.
The EU countries, Australia, Canada, and some US states have abolished capital punishment. The UN opposes the imposition of the death penalty under any circumstance, even for the most serious crimes. However, Bangladesh has retained the practice of death penalty as punishment.
Proponents of the death penalty say it is an important tool for preserving law and order, that it deters crime, and costs less than life imprisonment. They argue that retribution, or “an eye for an eye,” honours the victim, helps console grieving families, and ensures that the perpetrators of heinous crimes never have the opportunity to cause future tragedy.
Those who support capital punishment argue that all guilty people deserve to be punished in proportion to the severity of their crime. It is argued that death penalty provides closure for victims’ families. Some proponents of capital punishment argue it is beneficial for society overall. It is undeniable that those who have been executed cannot commit further crimes.
On the other hand, opponents of capital punishment say it has no deterrent effect on crime, that it wrongly gives governments the power to take human life, and it perpetuates social injustices by being racist and classist, disproportionately handing out punishment to minorities or the underprivileged. They say lifetime jail sentences are a more severe and less expensive punishment than death.
Everyone thinks human life is valuable. Opponents say everyone, even those who commit murder, have an inalienable right to their own life. Sentencing a person to death and executing them violates that right. Those against capital punishment believe that human life is so valuable that even the worst murderers should not be deprived of their right to live.
Those who are against capital punishment also argue that death penalty is wrong because it lowers the dignity of people, that it is a surrender to the worst that is in human beings, that it uses a sort of power – the official power to kill by execution – that has never elevated a society, never brought back a life, and never inspired anything but hate.
The most common and most cogent argument against capital punishment is that innocent people may also get killed because of mistakes or flaws in the justice system. Witnesses, (when they are part of the process), prosecutors, and jurors can all make mistakes. When this is coupled with flaws in the system, it is inevitable that sometimes innocent people will be convicted of crimes.
Where capital punishment is used, such mistakes cannot be set right. Another important and crucial argument against retribution is that it is immoral.
In addition to all these issues surrounding capital punishment, some argue that all ways of executing people cause so much suffering to the condemned person that they amount to torture, and are therefore wrong. Many methods of execution are quite likely to cause enormous suffering, such as beheading, execution by lethal gas, electrocution and so on.
A number of points can be made to logically argue against the death penalty. There is a better alternative: life without parole. The death penalty puts innocent lives at risk. Race and place determine who lives and who dies. Poor legal defence leaves many sentenced to death. Capital punishment does not deter crimes. There is a better way to help the families of murder victims. No civilian’s job description should include killing another person.
It may be noted that people are not born criminals. Rather, it is society that makes them criminals. Two of the main causes for crimes are fear and want. We know that human rights are freedom from fear and want. If we can enforce human rights effectively, then society will be automatically peaceful. Why should we go for punishments that cannot deter or stop crime? It would be good if the state could use them in better ways, keeping criminals in custody for life.
We are a developing steadily, our rate of education is increasing and our illiteracy rate is decreasing. The poverty level is going down and our per capita income has crossed $1000. More importantly, we are practicing the most sophisticated system of governance, democracy, which is supposed to protect human rights.
Bangladesh is a signatory of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the International Bill of Rights. So, Bangladesh might want to consider scrapping the death penalty from its penal code.
The death penalty might someday become unlawful in Bangladesh. It will, at that point, be a reflection of the larger social consensus that capital punishment is inhumane.