As Bangladesh witnesses a civil war-like scenario over the upcoming elections, the United Nations has been increasingly involved in its affairs. The UN Secretary General voicing strong concern over widespread election-related violence creates a sense of déjà vu as we have witnessed this scenario before. This time around, with the incumbent and opposition roles reversed, UN warnings to abide by international norms offer little solace to those injured and terrorised by opposition-launched attacks in the name of democracy.
From the UN secretary general calling the prime minister to condemn the ongoing violence, to UN Assistant Secretary General Oscar Fernandez-Taranco desperately attempting reconciliation between the warring parties, to UN High Commissioner Navi Pillay warning that Bangladeshi political leadership can face International Criminal Court prosecution for causing destructive brinkmanship, the UN has exhibited a high amount of interest in Bangladesh.
Although Mr Taranco tried to hold dialogues and reach a compromise, the winner-takes-all attitude prevailed, leading to the dysfunctional confrontational standpoint. Mr Taranco had also proposed election deferment and UN assistance in conducting the parliamentary election. Whereas UN statements and actions appear well-intended to create a peaceful, inclusive, and fair election process, how beneficial has the global international cooperation organisation been for Bangladesh?
Political observers will recall how the events of January 11, 2007 changed the course of history for Bangladesh. Former army chief General Moeen Ahmed stated that on that day, UN Undersecretary General Gueheno called him to warn that if the Bangladesh Army played a role in a one-sided election, the UN would consider withdrawing the nation’s armed forces from its peacekeeping operations.
Moreover, a US Embassy, Dhaka cable from January 12, 2007, reports that Brigadier Amin declared a number of reasons behind the military-issued state of emergency: The UN Secretary General’s concern on Bangladesh, the local UN representative specifically linking peacekeeping operations with military support for elections, and a letter from the UN linking military actions with peacekeeping.
The UN inciting a military takeover was a remarkable episode in its 60-year history as a global peacekeeping institution. The lucrative peacekeeping contracts were used as leverage; this was a carrot-and-stick approach by the UN to intervene in the nation’s internal political affairs. During 2007, Bangladesh’s peacekeeping contracts brought in $300 million annually, a significant sum for a cash-strapped nation; half of the funds went to the participating soldiers. The missions also provide the Bangladesh Army significant international exposure and are a significant point of pride.
As the military embarked upon ruling the nation from behind the curtain of a technocratic government, its notable successes included registering 80 million new voters and conducting the freest, fairest election in the nation, as judged by the international community. As protests were banned under the state of emergency, the nation was mostly safe from turmoil, except during the student-led riots of mid-2007 calling for restoration of democracy and disbandment of the army camp in Dhaka University.
The Anti Corruption Commission led an unprecedented campaign to eliminate corruption. Those who we thought were sky-high above the law were actually imprisoned. However, the military-installed caretaker government conducted mass arrests of politicians on spurious charges that blew away upon the changing of political winds, businessmen were arbitrarily detained and freed upon making payments to military officers, as noted by Human Rights Watch, and the entire anti-corruption drive fell like a house of cards when Mr Ten Percent flew off to Britain.
Although a Human Rights Commission was formed and the judiciary was formally separated from the executive, the commission has become a mouthpiece begging for justice and the court has gone back into the prime minister’s fold.
Historically, Bangladesh fought to gain a seat at the UN. Upon dual vetoes by the Chinese in 1972 and 1973, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman could finally address the UN General Assembly on September 24, 1974. UN assessments are highly valued by the Bangladesh government. Receiving a UN award in 2010 for reduction of maternal and childhood mortality is cited as a distinguished achievement by the administration. Being ranked 16th out of 74 UN recipient nations on foreign direct investment flows is notably promoted by Bangladesh Embassy in Washington, DC. The global body carries authoritative weight on judging Bangladesh’s successes and failures.
A few years back, I visited UN headquarters in New York City. Located by East River on an 18-acre site in Manhattan, the world landmark includes the 39-story Secretariat, General Assembly, conference, and library buildings. Inside the perimeter, a line of multicoloured flags depict 193 member states.
The tour starts from the General Assembly public lobby, leading to General Assembly hall, the central UN organ where member states discuss global issues requiring international cooperation.
The 1,800-person chamber holds a rostrum on front, with a green marble desk and matching lectern. The high ceiling is topped by a shallow dome ringed by light fixtures. Moreover, the chamber’s front portion is surrounded by a semicircular wall.
While trekking the halls, I noticed two South Asian gentlemen in suits and badges admiring a poster. One remarked to the other in Bengali: “The peacekeeping soldier in this photo is from Bangladesh.”
Currently, Bangladesh’s total contribution of uniformed personnel to UN peacekeeping operations is almost 8,000. This is the second-largest deployment among contributing nations and includes troops, police, and military experts. This source of national prestige and high revenue was utilised by the world’s international cooperation body in 2007 to avoid a one-sided election and the violence linked to it.
Whereas some civil society figures and organisations such as Asian Human Rights Commission have openly called for UN intervention “for saving ordinary people’s lives and liberties,” how much of a benefit will this have for the nation? After 42 years as a sovereign nation, if Bangladesh still requires international assistance for governance and holding elections, it has serious problems that must be remedied. The ultimate question is: Who helps Bangladesh when its leadership completely fails to safeguard its citizens? Is foreign intervention the nation’s only saviour to lift it out of this crisis?