Apparently the Indian PSA about sexual harassment is a violation of human rights, or so it would seem, from an article recently published in Dhaka Tribune (December 28).
It possibly tried to expose the double standards of society which simultaneously encourages and vilifies male sexuality. And, the double standard of women who are offended by lustful looks despite dressing in “low-cut low hips.” At the same time, the writer has managed to reach a very feminist position (although he might argue it’s a more holistic and truly egalitarian humanist position), and a very sexist one. Let me explain.
His position is feminist because unwittingly it identifies a core feminist concern – patriarchy. This is a system that ideally wants to see male sexuality as potent and dominant. It is patriarchy that teaches you, dear writer, and forces you, to stay up the ladder. In this system, sex is not a mutually satisfactory endeavour but an acquisition of pleasure.
In the messy reality, however, this can result in the demonisation of male sexuality where any man is a potential “pervert.” This is not women shortchanging you, this is patriarchy backfiring on you. You are, instead of acknowledging the existence of a bad system, trying to fix its little loopholes so you can get on with the program without any hassle.
The Mumbai ad itself is not necessarily feminist. But it gets across a point. The point is that this predator-prey mode of interaction, this age-old game of hide-and-seek where the female body is the “it,” where you score a point if you can get a peek, or get her to give you a peek – this is not a game women want to play.
Your moves and your victory dances are all happening with unwilling people. Often clothing isn’t sexual invitation, and even sexy attires are not permission to objectify. Even when you are invited, your response may still not be disrespectful to the host. In short, don’t pee in the pool.
Society does teach and encourage men to dehumanise and objectify women, and blaming the agents instead of the system can only go so far. Shouldn’t the attractive women also be blamed for following society’s dictates? This is why we need feminism: To point out the power disparity between sexes.
The men who harass women have the license from their society to look at women’s bodies in exclusion of their personhood and without any major repercussion. The best the unwilling recipients of this attention can do is to shame them (through an ad campaign, for example) and hope that the message sinks in.
Most women grow up knowing that their worth is directly proportional to their looks, then are vilified for trying to look as attractive as possible, and then get crucified for resisting the humiliation of objectification (and the harassment that follows).
Society has many ways of punishing women who don’t listen. The acceptance and encouragement of street harassment is one of the ways to regulate our lives. Women find many ways to work with the system. Slut shaming is a weapon designed to prevent women from manipulating the very system and use their sexuality to exercise power. Women may be victims, but not without agency.
What the ad apparently fails to convey is that maybe men and women shouldn’t have to interact within such a questionable system. That if they choose to interact sexually, it may be done in a way where all parties feel safe, secure and in control of what happens to their bodies.
The problem is not with men perceiving women as sexual beings. Attraction between people is natural and healthy. What women object to is the sheer disregard lookers have for the owner of the body.
The direct causation you feel between a woman’s clothing and your desire to leer is actually mediated by society’s attitude. Gradual changes in how women view the male body – from embarrassed to indifferent to appreciative – prove just that. Feigning helplessness in the hand of biology is wrong, because even what we would find attractive – height, width, complexion – is greatly dictated by norm.
You see this thing that we are doing – arguing over who should bear responsibility for street harassment – that is a political debate. This, my friend, is feminism.
Feminism is the activism to re-negotiate the balance of power between genders in a way that does not disfavour women and anything that is associated with femininity. The word humanism doesn’t work, because it takes away focus from the power imbalance and glosses over centuries of structurally embedded inequality.
Let’s talk some more about power and privilege. When women notice men in the streets, do they feel bad? Do women usually look at an attractive man in a way that makes him feel violated? Can women get away with it? These are questions of power. Not physical power, but a social one.
It’s entirely fair to raise questions about sexuality and human relationships, especially in societies where notions of propriety are changing, and the change is being interfered by consumerism. You can turn this into a zero sum battle between sexes where only one’s interest will take precedence.
Or you could turn this into a discussion about how to share responsibility and allowances, a conversation over keeping the public spaces between (and among) men and women reasonably desexualized, so all kinds of relationships can thrive. Be part of the solution, not the problem.