Irony is a word that is readily misused, particularly by the generations born in the 1980s and 1990s. Alanis Morissette’s famous song “Ironic” shoulders a lot of the blame for subjecting millions of people to a supposedly profound word and forcing upon them its various incorrect usages.
One might be tempted to turn to this word when thinking or talking about the tributes paid by Bangladeshi politicians to the now late great Nelson Mandela. There can be no doubt that human beings of his stature are rare to the point of being non-existent. However, when Bangladeshi leaders talk about Tata Mandela’s legacy being one of choosing reconciliation over revenge, peace and unity over hatred and discrimination, irony is somehow too small a word. There is merit in arguing that it is hypocritical, but that too somehow falls short.
The deeply divided nation is experiencing what is a civil war in all but name. While no one is asking, nor caring about what the people want, it does not matter because they are little more than a pawn and an inconvenience in the violent game that is being played out in the name of politics and democracy, fuelled by hate, discrimination and greed.
The facts remain that nameless people are dying, and that unnamed people are being paid to carry out these heinous acts. Regardless of who is behind all of this, the one thing that cannot be disputed is that none of this is acceptable in a civilised society in the 21st century.
What makes this particular strategy, one that has been adopted by the mafia and drug lords to great effect, even more distasteful, as if that was possible, is that children are involved. They are dying, and they are being used to carry out violent acts and supposed protests.
The inevitable escalation of violence in Bangladesh is attributable to the world’s belief in disproportional response. Global politics promulgates proportional response. Evidence suggests there is no such thing.
Kill an archduke, the world goes to war. A harbour that is a military base is attacked, drop a nuclear bomb on innocents. Two towers collapse, level two countries. There never has been, nor will there ever be proportionality in retribution, because retribution by definition is about crushing the other side since it is responsible for a slight, perceived or real.
The virtue of the principle of a proportional response is given credence as it is believed to be the one thing that forces nuclear powers to exercise restraint. Forgotten in that argument is Claude Eatherly, unwittingly complicit in the bombing of Hiroshima.
Horrified when he found out the consequences of his actions, he campaigned against nuclear proliferation and was discredited by the authorities. The Bangladeshi population is suffering from not having the likes of Eatherly in its midst, and from having an establishment that does not have the restraint that keeps superpowers from unleashing a nuclear holocaust.
Moreover, the argument about the bomb is one of morality, not proportionality. Sadly, this too is lacking in Bangladesh. Thus, all that remains is the doctrine of disproportional response that results in exponentially increasing violence every time either side acts.
The incomparably irresponsible Bangladeshi politicians can be counted on to be reliable about one thing: blaming the opposing faction. It is always the other side that is accused of unconscionable death, and the cost of lives is worn as a badge of honour that displays political strength.
Those who apparently know better, variously applaud such actions and their justifications, get on their high horses and deride such inhuman incidents, or arrogantly state that they had posited as much.
In the practice of indulging their egos so, they neither do anything to prevent the ludicrous repetitions and disproportional responses, nor give the populace the leadership and hope it so desperately needs in these never-ending testing, turbulent times. The sideshow of clairvoyants and savants, like the political strife, has gone on for too long.
The political system that passes for democracy in Bangladesh was birthed by one-time apostles, clothed as intellectuals, as those who know better. In reality, these apostates resuscitated ailing dynasties who have brought the nation to its knees and still show neither care nor remorse for their greed-induced actions lacking completely in reason.
Having found a second wind, they show no signs of going anywhere. Mandela is dead, and Bangladesh has been convicted. It will serve its punishment of being ruled by these dynasties because those who know so much have always done so little.