It takes two to tango

The AL game plan seems pretty clear to all by now. The party appears to have all but succeeded in its (admittedly not difficult) stratagem of goading the BNP into boycotting the elections. It makes a certain amount of sense. After all, if the BNP does not participate, then it can’t win and the AL can’t lose.

The only thing better for in incumbent government than no elections is elections the opposition does not contest, which, when you think about it, pretty much comes to the same thing for the voters.

The one problem that the AL faces is that this was precisely the BNP game plan in 1996 and 2007, and the AL’s position when it was in opposition then is identical to the BNP position now: one-sided elections are unacceptable and confer no legitimacy upon the winner.

The AL makes the same argument that the BNP made before it, that the elections will be constitutional, even though, in the present case, the argument is even more farcical than in the past, because the elections will only be constitutional because the AL amended the constitution to make them so.

The bottom line should be not what the AL or the BNP want, but what the people of this country want. The people of the country did not want the constitution amended to end the caretaker government and they do not want elections without the main opposition.

Even more worrisome for the long-term health of our polity than the government’s apparent contempt for public opinion when it comes to this issue is the fact that it looks increasingly as though, unlike in the past, this time a one-sided election will stick.

In 2007, the international community made it clear that one-sided elections would not be considered legitimate, even though AL grounds for boycotting that election were considerably weaker than the BNP grounds today. For the record, I agreed with the AL position then and find that basic intellectual honesty and consistency thus compels me to agree with the BNP position today.

What a difference six years makes, apparently. Now it seems as though both India and the US, the two crucial players in this sorry saga, will forsake principle for realpolitik (no surprise there, perhaps) to give their blessings to a one-sided election. The EU is still on the fence, but in the end they are only bit players in this drama.

That’s the way the cookie crumbles, I guess. It saddens me that the acceptability of Bangladeshi elections will be determined, in the final analysis, not by the Bangladeshi people but by outsiders who are concerned, naturally, more with their own national self-interest, and not ours.

Why does public opinion inside the country matter so little? The simple reason is that the BNP and its allies do not appear to have the muscle power to oppose the AL in the streets. In 1996 and 2007, the AL did have this muscle power, and that made the difference.

But surely one’s ability to muster goon squads in defense of one’s position should not be the measure of the rightness of the position or the measure of the merit of a political party. I for one am quite relieved that the BNP does not appear to have the muscle to press their case in the streets and that the government has the power to more or less keep things under control.

But what should that have to do with the upcoming elections? The test of the BNP should surely not be whether it can command sufficient shock troops to bring the country to a standstill, but whether it can command a majority of the vote at the polls.

In Bangladesh, it seems, we measure a party’s power and popularity, not by its strength at the ballot box, but by its strength on the streets. What a dismal reality. To be sure, often the two amount to the same thing, as indeed they did in 1996 and 2007. But not always, and not this year, if recent local election results and opinion polls are anything to go by.

More to the point, if strength on the streets is the only relevant measure of a political party, then it is little wonder that our political parties have evolved into such thuggish entities and there is so little space for reform of the system.

Pushing through a one-sided election would mean that the BNP and its allies would be punished, not for the mayhem and misery they have caused over the past months, but for the fact that they have not been able to cause more. No prizes for guessing where a dynamic like that ends.

Whether one is a supporter of BNP or AL or neither party or no party, we all need to recognise that if we don’t create space for a politics of the people, divorced from the politics of the street (read: armed cadres), then we are doomed to end up being ruled by those who will be least scrupulous in ensuring that they win the arms race to the bottom.