Bob Dylan’s “Blowin’ in the wind” has been described as a protest song. The American musician, singer, and songwriter is famous for his anti-war music and comes to our minds especially now, because of the widespread violence and killing during hartals.
Hartals were first used in the Indian Independence Movement. It is an extensive protest, engaging shutdown of shops, markets, workplaces, and educational institutions. This non-cooperation must be voluntarily observed and is a common weapon for getting demands fulfilled.
Any organisation can call for a strike. It can campaign and motivate people to support the event, but nobody can coerce general people into participating in it. Unfortunately, just that has been happening for the last 23 years.
Staging hartals is a democratic right, no doubt, but the right comes with responsibility. You have to abide by certain rules if you want to enjoy a right. You cannot take people’s lives and torch their assets in the name of democratic right.
You have to take responsibility for the destruction caused. On the other hand, the ruling party can never interrupt the right to protest. The ruling party affiliated student wing has continuously attacked and disposed of the protestors, in some cases while law-enforcing agencies are standing beside them.
An opposition party never accepts this scenario. Rather, it helps the opposition to strike in a defiant manner. The government not only interrupts the already violent organisations but also muscles the social movements and left-wing organisations who are recognised as non-violent disciplined groups.
Hartals have undoubtedly become a legitimate affair of killing, torching, vandalising. In this year, at least 50 people were killed and more than a hundred injured due to vindictive attacks by the pickets. Look at the burnt and dead people, you are responsible.
They belong to neither of the parties. They did not defy or support the hartal. They were just trying to make a living. How will you answer to their kin, to their crying needs?
It is not solely any party, rather, both major parties must bear the liability for mass death and killing. They are responsible for this belligerent trend. They are responsible for around 3,000 lives lost for the last two decades.
Nowadays people are utterly fed up with the two major parties and their approach to protests. People might not like the government. They even have an aversion to the opposition’s violent protests.
General strikes cause immense harm to our national wealth, economy, and education. We have to come to a political consensus on how an organisation can protest to its extreme, what are the rules they must maintain, what are the new formats of struggle, who will take the liability of losses, how the government ensures people’s security.
We know there are several countries where there are places to stage demonstrations. The protagonists can attend and show support, and the antagonists can easily carry on with their daily business.
There are many queries, and much anticipation. There is still optimism in our minds. Maybe the answer is blowin’ in the wind.