Cutting the baby in half

We all know the story of the Judgement of Solomon. Two young women come to King Solomon of Israel (or the Prophet Sulaiman, as he is known in the Quran), each claiming to be the mother of a baby boy. After hearing their competing claims, Solomon calls for his sword and decrees that the only fair solution is to cut the baby in half, with each woman receiving half the baby.

No sooner does he issue his decree then the presumed true mother withdraws her claim, begging him to spare the child and give him to the other woman, preferring that the child live, even if it means that he will no longer be hers, whereas the presumed false mother responds by telling him to go ahead and cut the baby in half, as he has proposed.

In this way, Solomon deduces who the true mother is, the presumption being that the true mother would rather see the baby live than be cut in half, even if it means giving him up, while the one who is willing to see the baby cut in half rather than relinquish her claim could not possibly be his true mother.

Yes, yes, very clever, very wise, so stipulated. But hold on a minute. How would he have figured it out if both of the mothers had folded their arms across their chests and said: Fine, go ahead. He wouldn’t have looked too wise then, would he? Of course, he might have then come to the determination that whichever one of the women might be the true mother, that neither deserved the child, and he might not have been far wrong.

You see, there is a second point to the story, that has nothing to do with the great king and prophet and his wisdom and sagacity. The point has to do with how we determine devotion and whether someone is really looking out for someone else, or is just motivated by their own selfish self-interest.

His solution would not have worked had both the women agreed to cut the baby in half. The underlying premise to the whole story is that if you really have something or someone’s best interests at heart then you would rather give up your claim to that person or thing, even if it is rightfully yours, than to see it destroyed.

Well.

By this token, it seems clear that neither the prime minister nor the leader of the opposition can be said to have shown much evidence of caring overly for the nation they have ruled in turn for over two decades and its long-suffering inhabitants. The past two decades of political warfare demonstrate pretty unequivocally the point that both of them would rather destroy this country than let the other have it.

When in opposition, both the AL and the BNP have devoted themselves single-mindedly to violent confrontation and non-cooperation to make the country so ungovernable that the ruling party will be chased from office in failure and disgrace at the end of its term.

They have so far succeeded every time, as it happens, but at the cost of the nation, which has had to suffer the hartals and killings and the economic and sociologic consequences of these scorched earth tactics.

This kind of maneuver is not unique to Bangladesh, by any means (see, e.g., Republican Party, United States). But nowhere in the world has this kind of oppositional strategy taken such an extreme form as it has in Bangladesh, and it seems axiomatic that any party (here or elsewhere) that employs these tactics cannot credibly claim to be acting in the national interest.

Both sides would argue that they are motivated by love for their country and the bottomless iniquity of the other side, that to allow the other side to either continue to rule or come to power would be a greater disaster than any that they are visiting on the country at present, and that it is only to save the country from the horrors of AL or BNP (please choose one, as appropriate), that they are forcing such suffering on us. And it is all the other side’s fault, anyway.

It’s a vaguely plausible argument, but if you fall for that one, I’ve got a bridge over the Padma River I’d like to sell you. Simply put, the current crisis is occasioned not by a difference of opinion over who will govern us come next year, but on the rules for how to conduct the upcoming elections to decide who will govern us.

AL could conceivably win an election under a caretaker government and BNP could conceivably win one without one. But this is a proposition neither side is willing to take any kind of chance on, and the death, destruction, mayhem, and misery they are more than happy to rain down on all of our heads, instead of giving way on this one point, tells us everything we need to know about whose best interests they have at heart (hint: not ours).

The party which backs down and gives in on the caretaker government issue rather than put the country through any more of the devastation it has suffered is the one that will have my respect, as it would have demonstrated that it has at least a modicum of respect for the national interest.

But as of right now, both sides are saying: Go ahead and cut the baby in half. The people of Bangladesh can draw their own conclusions. Solomon had it easy.