On an ordinary day in Kalyanpur in May this year, Md Russel was allegedly abducted by 20 to 25 men after refusing a Tk15,000 monthly extortion demand. They took him into a slum and beat him until locals heard his cries and intervened. Two days later, he filed a police complaint. But instead of investigating, police reportedly urged him to settle the matter with the accused.
For Russel, filing a complaint did not lead to an investigation. His experience raises questions about police discretion and whether people can seek justice without being pressured by those they accused. This one incident cannot represent the entire justice system, but it shows how institutional practices affect people’s ability to exercise their rights.
Like many stories across Bangladesh, this reminds us that human rights violations are not abstract. They are lived, contested, and silenced at the intersection of class, gender, and power.
Understanding human rights requires more than knowing what the law guarantees. We must understand why some can claim those rights while others cannot.
The limits of a legal lens
We speak of human rights in legal terms. The Constitution guarantees equality of all before the law, freedom of speech, and protection against arbitrary arrest. Bangladesh is a signatory to major human rights treaties. Rights are framed as legal entitlements to be claimed, defended, or litigated.
Yet, law can tell us what rights exist, but not why some exercise them more easily than others.
Legal anthropologist Sally Engle Merry showed how human rights are reshaped as they move across societies and institutions. Rights acquire meaning through local contexts, social relations, and everyday practices. To understand whether rights are protected, we must look beyond legal documents to see how individuals exercise them.
In the Chittagong Hill Tracts, indigenous communities see land not as property but as ancestral identity. When the state applies land laws designed for flatland ownership, it challenges these cultural meanings.
As Signe Leth of the International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs notes, land is not just a commodity for Indigenous Peoples but a part of their identity, spirituality, and life.
The same gap appears in the experience of the hijra community. Recognition as a third gender in 2013 did not automatically remove the stigma and exclusion that shape access to housing, education, healthcare, and employment.
Changing the law and changing social relations are not the same thing. These examples show how culture and social norms shape rights, a concern central to Anthropology.
Garment workers’ experiences show how workplace hierarchy, gender, and class affect the ability to claim rights. Despite the Labour Act's protections, a 2025 study of 332 female garment workers found that 22$ of workers reported frequent sexual harassment inside the factories during the preceding six months by supervisors, male co-workers, and security guards.
For workers who depend on their wages, fear of job loss and retaliation can make formal protection difficult to claim. Applying a sociological lens shows that while a right may be guaranteed by law, whether someone can exercise it depends on their social circumstances.
Human rights also depend on institutions capable of enforcing the laws. A UN fact-finding report on the July-August 2024 violence in Bangladesh documented how weak internal oversight and barriers to prosecuting public officials hindered accountability. When complaints are handled by institutions implicated in abuses, victims may have little assurance of independent investigation or meaningful redress.
Finally, understanding human rights requires looking at the material conditions of freedom. When a child in a coastal village loses access to school due to flooding, or when a family is displaced by river erosion and cannot recover their livelihood, the problem is not just environmental or economic. It affects their ability to exercise basic rights.
A BIGD study of social assistance in Satkhira found that beneficiary selection could be shaped by kinship networks, political affiliation, gender, religious identity, and proximity to local representatives, despite formal eligibility criteria.
Economic vulnerability can also make travel, paperwork, legal support, and time away from work difficult to afford. Amartya Sen’s capability approach reminds us that freedom is not merely possessing a right, but having the real opportunity to use it.
Across these examples, rights are shaped by more than laws. They are shaped by the institutions people encounter, social hierarchies they live within, and the resources available to them.
A more human understanding of rights
If law is the pillar of rights, social science is its foundation. Each discipline offers a lens: Law defines rights and duties, anthropology reveals cultural meanings, sociology exposes inequality and social hierarchy, political science examines institutions and power, and development economics shows how material conditions affect freedom. Together, they reveal what a strictly legal lens cannot explain.
Bangladesh has made progress, from women’s participation to digital access. Yet persistent inequalities, gender-based violence, institutional weakness, and social exclusion remind us that rights cannot be legislated into existence. They must be supported by social and institutional change.
That includes complaint and redress mechanisms that protect complainants, stronger institutional oversight, and fewer financial and social barriers for marginalized groups.
Interdisciplinary research can strengthen rights protection by showing where rights on paper fail in practice and by involving affected communities in judging whether reform works.
Sanjid Tahsin Rakin is a research associate at the Brac Institute of Governance and Development (BIGD), Brac University.