Sixty years ago, the idea of everyone having a video phone in their pocket was the stuff of science fiction.
That people might spend more time on devices doing things other than making actual phone calls would have seemed stranger still, but here we are. A world where fretting about the impact of our own and other peoples’ screen time on society is a more likely choice to make than going without a phone.
As with climate change, individual decisions and consumer choices count enough to make a difference, but most of the actual power to substantively improve regulations and standards rests with politicians and giant global corporations.
In the run-up to the US mid-term Congressional elections this month, Silicon Valley companies and their owners donated $600 million dollars to Republican candidates.
A large proportion of this came from Elon Musk spending about $200m on supporting Ken Paxton, the losing Republican candidate for a Senate seat in Texas.
Whilst the vast amounts given to Republican candidates did not prevent an anti-Trump wave of Democratic party successes, they reflect the growing amounts being spent by Silicon Valley titans on buying political influence.
Big Tech’s societal and environmental footprint and its record of abusing monopolistic positions, aggressively minimizing paying taxes, failing to safeguard privacy, and designing algorithms to addict users and profit from amplifying political extremes and other harmful content already raises many ethical questions. Yet, the latest spending added to the concerns about its political lobbying and future trajectory.
Moore’s law, named after a co-founder of Intel, observed that the number of transistors it is technically possible to fit onto an integrated circuit can be doubled every two years at little increase in cost. For decades it was this rate of exponential improvement that enabled ever more computing power to be made available at lower prices to ordinary consumers.
In turn, these underpinned bigger projections and valuations for the sector. In 2016, the world’s most valuable company by market capitalization was Apple with the aggregate value of its shares peaking above $500bn.
Ten years on, its value is ten times larger at $5 trillion. This is different from being the world’s largest company by actual revenue; Apple’s revenues place it as only the seventh largest company.
Apple’s stock market value reflects the willingness of investors to bet on the tech sector’s future growth. Since 2020 this optimism has become based less on Moore’s law delivering cost reductions for consumers -- its effect is slowing down as semiconductor manufacturers adjust to the growing complexity and cost of making ever smaller circuits just as global supply chains have fragmented -- and more on a belief in future profits from AI.
Potential impacts of AI, both positive and negative, are easy enough to imagine, given the pace of change the sector is promising. Predictions of technological dystopias and utopias are a hardy staple of speculative fiction.
Right now, AI has an insatiable appetite for capital investment in scaling up computational power and data centres. These are demanding ever greater amounts of electricity and water for cooling systems.
The cost neutral arithmetic of energy costs remaining stable as computer chips and systems become smaller and more powerful promised by Moore’s law has been turned completely upside down by a globalized gold rush to grow AI.
Even in a world that had free energy, this direction of travel would be controversial given the sector’s impact on jobs, but in a world with a growing population seeking to cut carbon emissions, amid plenty of pre-existing concerns about Big Tech, it is politically toxic.
Seen in this light, the sectors’ growing political donations and lobbying efforts on AI, not just in the United States, but in countries around the world, are easy to explain.
Like other industries, it wants to keep pipelines of investment flowing and persuade politicians to support them with financial incentives and favourable laws.
But what if it is all just snake oil and a digital Ponzi scheme?
Scepticism is a rational stance given the vast scope and impact of the IT sector. But even where politicians seek to regulate aspects of the sector, their actions tend to be limited or seem like locking a stable door after the horse has bolted.
Given that parts of the sector like digital cryptocurrencies were designed to be largely decentralized and unregulated in nature, such naivete is troubling given that aspects of it can be used to enable criminality.
Dogmatic faith in future growth and cultish attitudes towards IT founders and products abound around the sector and among many consumers. Perhaps not surprisingly, many of the biggest critics of the ownership structures and strategies of the sector come from within its highly educated workforce and support the open-source movement.
Of course, the argument that technology is simply a tool that can be used for good or bad is ostensibly an objective one.
But when those making it are tech giants with monopolistic tendencies that stand to profit either way, calls for democratic scrutiny, breaking up monopolies, public accountability, and for that matter public ownership, all deserve to be heard.
It’s the oligarchs, stupid.
Niaz Alam is London Bureau Chief, Dhaka Tribune.