In the interconnected landscape of modern South Asia, the digital square was once heralded as a beacon of democratic expression. Today, however, it increasingly resembles a medieval plaza where a baying mob gathers, stones in hand, waiting for the next target to be dragged into the light.
Across India, Pakistan, and the wider region, whenever tragedy strikes or a viral controversy erupts, a familiar and sickening ritual unfolds online. Behind a shroud of anonymous handles, inactive profile pictures, and automated bot networks, a pervasive strain of digital chauvinism rears its head.
These faceless commentators rush with predatory speed to demean, judge, and ultimately blame women for their own suffering.
Whether it is a high-profile criminal case of rape and murder, a domestic abuse tragedy, or a viral public misstep, the verdict from this digital jury is always preemptive and predictable: The woman is guilty.
This phenomenon is not merely an annoyance of modern internet culture; it is a profound social rot.
It reveals a deep-seated, short-sighted misogyny that weaponizes human suffering to reinforce archaic prejudices, demanding that we confront and socially shun these insidious behaviours before they erode the moral fabric of our societies.
The anatomy of victim-blaming
The most harrowing manifestation of this online malice occurs in the wake of heinous crimes -- rapes, assaults, and murders that shock the public conscience.
In a just society, a horrific crime against a woman should provoke universal outrage, sorrow, and an uncompromising demand for justice against the perpetrator.
Yet, in the virtual echo chambers of South Asia, the narrative is routinely subverted.
When a woman is attacked or killed, the digital inquisitors immediately pivot away from the perpetrator’s guilt to dissect the victim’s life with microscopic scrutiny.
Why was she out alone at night? Where was her male guardian or family member? What was she wearing?
In cases involving minors, the depravity sinks even lower, with commentators bizarrely projecting adult anxieties onto children, questioning their clothing or presence in public spaces as if to rationalize the unrationalizable.
This is the quintessence of victim-blaming. It is a psychological defense mechanism rooted in a fragile worldview that cannot bear the thought of a chaotic, dangerous world where women are independent agents.
By blaming the victim, these commentators construct a comforting illusion of control: “If she hadn’t done X, Y, or Z, she would have been safe.”
In doing so, they absolve the actual criminal and place the burden of virtue and safety entirely on the shoulders of women.
It sends a chilling message to half the population: Your safety is conditional, and if you step outside the narrow parameters dictated by society, your tragedy is your own fault.
Attire, liberty, and the ‘liberal mind’
Beyond violent crimes, everyday viral controversies draw the same predatory swarm.
Let a video surface of a woman making a mistake in public, navigating a personal dispute, or simply living her life on her own terms, and the social media comment sections transform into cesspools of moral panic.
Here, the faceless profiles deploy a standard checklist of grievances.
Every complex socio-economic issue, every cultural shift, and every personal failure is summarily blamed on "indecent attire," "polygamous behaviour" (often invoked as a catch-all insult), and the dreaded "liberal mind."
If a woman exercises agency over her life, her career, or her relationships, she is immediately branded as a corrupting influence on traditional values.
The underlying rhetoric is transparently hypocritical: Men can indulge in every conceivable excess without denting their moral standing, but a woman’s entire character is judged by a single snapshot, a rumour, or a manipulated video clip.
Commentators jump on these bandwagons without a second thought for context, nuance, or basic human empathy.
Facts do not matter to the mob. Once the narrative is set -- that women have become too "modern," too "independent," and too "uncontrolled" -- the digital machinery of character assassination goes into overdrive.
From faceless bots to female envy
What makes this digital ecosystem particularly toxic is its composition.
It is propelled not just by men hiding behind pseudonyms, but also by a distinct psychological undercurrent of internalized misogyny.
On one hand, we have the legions of nameless male profiles -- the virtual moral police whose own lives are often defined by frustration, stagnation, and a deep-seated insecurity regarding modern, autonomous women.
Their online vitriol is an outlet for impotent rage against a changing world where women refuse to remain silent, subservient second-class citizens.
Protected by the anonymity of a screen, these men project their anxieties onto viral targets, seeking a toxic sense of community and validation from other like-minded misogynists.
On the other hand, we must confront an uncomfortable truth: This phenomenon is not exclusively male.
Often, women themselves participate in the shaming, driven by a potent mix of social conditioning and deep-seated envy. In societies where female worth has historically been tied to strict conformity, seeing another woman break the mold can trigger a defensive reaction.
Some women, having internalized patriarchal standards to survive, view independent or non-conformist women as a threat to the fragile security they have carved out for themselves.
By joining the mob, they signal their own "purity" and conformity. This betrayal from within is perhaps the most tragic aspect of the cycle, as it fractures solidarity precisely when it is needed most.
Call for social ostracization
We have reached a critical juncture in the digital evolution of South Asia. The line between online commentary and real-world harm has long since blurred.
When internet trolls normalize victim-blaming, they create a cultural climate where violence against women is minimized, excused, or implicitly encouraged.
This behaviour cannot simply be brushed aside as "just internet noise" or the ramblings of "trolls being trolls."
These voices shape public perception, intimidate survivors into silence, and deter women from seeking justice or participating fully in public life.
Combating this requires a fundamental cultural reset.
We must strip away the digital armour that emboldens these cowards.
Anonymity on social media should no longer be a free pass to terrorize victims of crime or ruin reputations with impunity.
Platforms must be held accountable for enabling networks of abuse and algorithmic amplification of misogyny.
More importantly, the remedy must come from society itself.
These shamelessly insensitive remarks and baseless accusations must be actively confronted and socially shunned.
Just as we would condemn someone for making excuses for a thief or a murderer in a physical room, we must call out those who excuse abuse and degradation in the digital room.
Friends, family members, colleagues, and community leaders must make it clear that victim-blaming and casual misogyny are not "opinions" to be debated -- they are moral failures.
Until the cost of participating in online harassment becomes too high -- until social circles, workplaces, and public platforms make it socially untenable to bully and blame women -- the digital public square will remain a dangerous frontier.
It is time to drag these faceless inquisitors out of the shadows and hold them to the light of accountability.
Women in our society deserve nothing less than a culture that protects their dignity, respects their autonomy, and refuses to negotiate with the malice of the mob.
Wafiur Rahman looks after the business desk at Dhaka Tribune.