The Constitution of Bangladesh promises its citizens freedom of speech and expression under Article 39, a right that lies at the heart of any democratic society.
Yet, in practice, this freedom is increasingly constrained by the very laws meant to regulate the digital space. The Digital Security Act 2018 (DSA), and more recently the Cyber Security Act 2023 (CSA), raised serious concerns about the erosion of this constitutional guarantee through vague and overbroad legal provisions.
At the centre of the problem is the principle of legal certainty, a cornerstone of the vagueness doctrine. This doctrine requires that criminal laws be drafted with sufficient precision so that individuals can reasonably understand what conduct is prohibited.
When laws fail to meet this standard, they open the door to arbitrary enforcement. Terms such as “false,” “offensive,” and “propaganda,” repeatedly used are inherently subjective and lack clear legal definition. As a result, citizens are left to navigate a legal landscape where the boundaries of lawful expression are unclear.
Sections such as Section 21 of the DSA and Section 25 of the CSA exemplified this problem. Their broad wording allows authorities to interpret online speech in ways that can criminalize ordinary commentary, satire, or criticism.
In effect, the ambiguity of these provisions shifts power away from clear legal rules and towards discretionary enforcement. This not only undermines the rule of law but also creates an environment of uncertainty and fear.
The consequences are not merely theoretical, they are borne out in practice. Between September 2018 and January 2023, more than 7,000 cases were filed under the DSA, yet only a small fraction reached resolution.
A significant number of accused individuals were arrested, often before any meaningful judicial scrutiny could take place. The CSA, despite being introduced as a reform, retained many of these structural flaws. It continued to permit arrests without warrants based on broadly defined “cyber-security risks,” further weakening procedural safeguards.
This pattern of enforcement produces what legal scholars describe as a “chilling effect.” When individuals are unsure whether their speech might expose them to criminal liability, they are more likely to self-censor.
Journalists may avoid sensitive reporting, activists may hesitate to speak out, and ordinary citizens may refrain from expressing dissenting views. Over time, this silent withdrawal from public discourse weakens democratic accountability itself.
The concerns raised by these laws are not confined to domestic debate. International human rights organizations, including Amnesty International, ARTICLE 19, and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), have repeatedly criticized both the DSA and CSA.
Their assessments consistently point to incompatibility with global standards on freedom of expression and due process, particularly those outlined in international human rights instruments to which Bangladesh is a party.
Comparative constitutional practice further highlights the issue. Courts in jurisdictions such as the United States, India, and the European Union have struck down laws that suffer from similar vagueness. These decisions reinforce a fundamental legal principle: That restrictions on speech must be narrowly tailored, clearly defined, and proportionate to a legitimate aim.
Vague and overly broad provisions fail this test because they grant excessive discretion to authorities while offering insufficient protection to individuals.
Bangladesh’s current framework falls short of this standard. While the need to address genuine cyber threats, such as online fraud, data breaches, and digital harassment, is undeniable, such regulation must not come at the expense of fundamental rights. Security and liberty are not mutually exclusive; rather, they must be carefully balanced through precise and accountable lawmaking.
Reform is therefore not only desirable but necessary. First, ambiguous terms within the existing laws must be clearly defined or removed altogether. Second, stronger procedural safeguards should be introduced, including stricter conditions for arrest and greater judicial oversight. Finally, any restriction on speech should be narrowly framed to target specific harms, rather than broadly capturing legitimate expression.
The government has a constitutional commitment to protect the voices of citizens. Laws that obscure the limits of permissible speech risk turning that promise into an illusion.
If Bangladesh is to uphold its democratic ideals, it must ensure that its cyber laws protect not only digital security but also the fundamental freedoms that define the nation’s constitutional identity.
Maymuna Mizan is a freelance contributor and a student of law.