Gone fishing

There's a ban on crab harvesting during the breeding season over in the Sundarbans -- good. This means that next year there will be more crab to be harvested which is good both for the fishermen and our ability to eat more yummy crab.

But given that this is a column about economics, it's also more than that -- it's darn good economic policy.

The basic problem here is something called the Tragedy of the Commons. Crabs are just out there, anyone willing to go and collect them can do so and 22 thousand and more fishermen do.

Yes, there might be a licence system but come along now, let's not think that's going to be hugely effective.

This is what is known as “Marxian” access to a resource (no, not Marxist). Anyone who wants can arrive and have some.

The problem being that if lots do, then there won't be any left.

If demand for, and harvesting of, an open access resource is greater than the regeneration of that resource, then it will run out.

This is true of grazing for animals, fish in the sea, spectrum for mobile phones, and many other things.

This was all laid out by Garrett Hardin half a century ago with a little amusement to it. He applied it to the human population and that's actually one thing it doesn't apply to -- but there we are.

The insight is correct at times, even if the example used wasn't correct.

Hardin went on to point out that we have two potential solutions to this.

One, we can make that resource private property -- a capitalist solution. Say, the farmer owns his fields and decides how much grazing there is going to be -- private property and capitalist.

Two, we can use government and regulation, Hardin called this the socialist answer. Here we've a limitation on crab harvesting issued by the government -- this is the socialist answer in this system of classification.

Elinor Ostrom, the first woman to win the Nobel Prize for Economics, got her medal for pointing out there's a third method.

Humans are not actually -- or not always -- stupid and so some communities will work together to impose their own restrictions on the use of such common assets.

This must be true as there are such common resources which people have been using for hundreds, perhaps thousands, of years without them running out.

Ostrom also pointed out that this really only works where social pressure within the community works to limit behaviour.

This is, in an important sense, the same insight that Muhammad Yunus had with his microfinance -- it works where the social pressure from the local community to repay is strong enough and not where it doesn’t.

It depends upon friends and neighbours having enough power over local actions to make sure the rules are obeyed.

Twenty two thousand fishermen is well above the Ostrom limit of perhaps two or three thousand people where such social pressures worked.

So, to make sure that there is crab next season, the season after, and so on, we've got to limit the fishing for crab in the here and now.

We could, possibly, allocate the crab catch from this little area to this man, from the next to another, and so on -- like farmers with fields. A little difficult really even though the idea has been shown to work in some deep sea fisheries.

So, we're left with this “socialist” solution. The government makes rules about when people may harvest crabs. Not doing so during the breeding season seems most sensible, obviously. But it is still, in this use of the word, “socialist.”

Which could be said to pose a problem for a free market and capitalist liberal like myself -- and you.

For if “socialism” works then why shouldn't we have lots and lots more of it?

To which the answer is we only use socialism -- or government -- when capitalism and free markets don't work.

I'm entirely willing to agree that this is true sometimes and, to be honest, so should all of us.

But how often is this true?

And the answer is not all that often and therefore government, socialism, is something to be had in small but necessary quantities rather than the way our lives are ruled.

Sometimes, yes, but not often.

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.