Preventing medical malpractices

A very close relative of mine had a heart attack recently. On the way to an “expensive hospital,” he lost consciousness. He didn’t have any heartbeat when he was taken to the ICU, but the cardiologists of that hospital brought his pulse back after a few minutes of CPR (cardiopulmonary resuscitation). However as it turned out his brain wasn’t responding.

That is how he spent 20 days, and at the end of the fifteenth day, he was seen developing a huge bedsore on his back. After 30 days, when his brain was trying to come back, his other organs began failing due to infection acquired from the bedsore. In the end, he died. In another incident, my uncle-in-law needed to remove one of his kidneys. As it turned out, the surgeon opened up the wrong side. Upon realising his mistake, he closed it and opened up the side that needed surgery.

These are only two examples of negligence from medical professionals. Preventing bedsore isn’t very difficult these days. Often using a certain type of air-mattresses can help combat almost all types of bedsore. Perhaps my uncle-in-law could have been saved, had he not developed the bedsore. However, since he had an almost-incurable damage in his brain, we didn’t raise any issue over his bedsore and went home with his lifeless body. But the second incident, where the surgeon sliced open the wrong side of the kidney patient, was something we couldn’t forgive.

Mistakes such as these aren’t new in Bangladesh; they happen virtually every day. Merely googling the phrase “chikitshoker obohela” (negligence of physician) in Bangla, will reveal the sheer number of reported malpractice cases that happens and it is enough to flabbergast anyone.

There are at least a thousand news items in the media on alleged medical maltreatments. These reports describe how people are dying due to the negligence of physicians and hospital authorities, and as well as being prescribed with wrong treatment. The reports also describe how the alleged victim’s relatives ransack hospital premises after their dear ones pass away. Some relatives of victims in this country do file cases against the alleged negligence of the doctors, but we don’t get to know what happens to those cases later on as the media stops following them up after a certain time. Most of the people who receive wrong treatments or become subject to malpractices go home quietly without lodging any complaint, be it to the hospital or to the government.

When a student dies of any malpractice, his/her friends stage protest rallies at the hospital concerned, the authorities then agree to compensate the death. Otherwise, there is absolutely no provision for any investigation or compensation in this country.

In fact, the provision for patients seeking redress in case of any medical malpractice isn’t there in this country. The definition for “medical malpractice” is not known to any common citizen of Bangladesh.

Now, what’s actually the legal definition of medical malpractice? Jason Konvicka in Forbes magazine writes: “Medical malpractice occurs when a health-care provider deviates from the recognised ‘standard of care’ in the treatment of a patient. The ‘standard of care’ is defined as what a reasonably prudent medical provider would or would not have done under the same or similar circumstances. In essence, it boils down to whether the provider was negligent.”

Having said that, we must say that there’s a complete disregard to this fact by our medical practitioners as well as hospital authorities. The fact that practice of medical science requires highest amount of accountability has been always overlooked here. This is a profession of saving lives, but our doctors and hospital authorities behave as though they are doing a big favour to the patients.

The government and opposition parties, on the other hand, seem to be busy involving doctors of the country in various political activities. Of course the government have been seen to organise raids on the quacks, but how the certificate-holders are allegedly neglecting their duties has not at all been taken into consideration.

This is totally different in other countries where doctors and hospitals have to answer each and every alleged medical malpractice. The physicians in those countries face confiscation of their licences if they fail to provide satisfactory answers to any complaint of malpractice.

Perhaps the time has come for formulating laws on medical malpractice in Bangladesh so that the patients who become victims of wrong treatment or negligence can seek redress from the court of law. At the same time, the doctors and hospital authorities can also be made properly accountable as far as their profession is concerned.