Can we bring back the bull?

It was 2nd December 2005. I went to Telenor headquarters in Oslo, Norway to convince their top brass to list Grameenphone, a Telenor subsidiary with Dhaka Stock Exchange and share their successes with the common people of Bangladesh.

Since joining as the Chairman of Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Mirza Azizul Islam thought that unless he could bring in large companies like Grameenphone, he cannot create synergy in the Bangladesh capital market and gave me a mandate to attract Grameenphone to list locally.

His mandate became pretty strong when he took over as finance and planning adviser in the interim government led by his friend Fakhruddin Ahmed, who thought in the similar way to strengthen Bangladesh capital market.

With lot of efforts with the regulators including the National Board of Revenue (NBR), stock exchanges and most importantly sleepless nights of our colleagues at Citi Global Markets home and abroad, we could list Grameenphone with the local bourses after almost four years.

Though my professional engagement didn’t allow me to go anywhere near to buying any Grameenphone shares, I was extremely happy to list the largest conglomerate in Bangladesh with the capital market. Thank God, Grameenphone shares are being traded well and Grameenphone management and the employees are keeping their flag flying high day in day out.

Afterwards we did try with Aktel, Robi, and Banglalink also. Since they were yet to become profitable, SEC could not help them much with the required approvals. Our efforts to list few other large local companies also failed since we could not confirm high “price discovery” for them. Many of them unfortunately wanted to intervene with the regulators to jack up their price. We obviously could not support their desire.

Bangladesh capital market, though identified as a frontier market, is still dominated by retail investors, weak or no research and manoeuvred by few biggies only. These biggies in the past were seen to be too manipulative and drove the market as a “cartel.”

If I am being allowed to be frank and to do justice to the regulators too, Bangladesh capital market was never allowed to run on its own. Regulators were weak or most of them didn’t have clear visibility about the destination.

There were serious capacity issues within the regulatory body, or the controlling ministry was never sure how far they should allow SEC to decide on their own. Other than the retired government servants, we seldom did see any chartered accountant, masters of business administration or law being appointed there. Their information technology platform or data mining was always very poor and reflected through weak monitoring and supervision of the market. The government’s top office was many times found involved even in the election of a local bourse headman. Few “manipulators” were trying to decide on selection of the “top regulator” in this sector too.

I must say things started to move in the right direction during the fag end of this government. SEC is now little more capacitated and empowered. They have been able to issue few guidelines in order to streamline the market and more importantly restrict evil activities. Corporate governance guideline is out.

Ministry of finance is almost on the finishing line towards approval of the financial reporting act (FRA), in order to ensure better disclosures for the investors. Surveillance on the operating companies has also improved. One or two accountants and lawyers appointed at SEC are trying to do a good job.

However, even with improved situation SEC could not attract good companies into the market. They also were not successful to bring back confidence into the market. Market confidence is one of the lowest in recent times. Index has dropped below four thousand mark and more shockingly people are withdrawing from the market and liquidity is pretty low.

I think it is no more an issue of punishing some culprits close to the “power house” only. We need to move with some systemic approach. Guidelines have been upgraded. De-mutualisation of the bourses is now becoming a reality within short time. People at SEC have been trained and empowered than in the past.

Unfortunately, we are not seeing much change in the way banks and merchant banks or securities houses operate. Nor are there signs of improvement in the way retail investors invest in the market, market research or investment research. And more importantly we constantly try to attract better and larger companies to list with the capital market.

Large companies in Bangladesh very much want to become the owner of a merchant bank or brokerage house, but don’t want to list any of their entities with the capital market. There is no ceiling to how much these large companies can borrow from the bank and financial institutions and more shockingly – unlike other countries – their borrowing limit has never been linked to their capital and reserve.

For obvious reasons, good companies with better earnings are reluctant to list. They rather want to be bank financed at 14-15% interest rate instead of diluting their stakes with other shareholders. Weak or relatively smaller size companies look at capital markets only for short time gains, not for expansion of their plants or businesses. Therefore, most of their aim is to jack up the price in every possible way.

Attached to this is also lack of governance or inability to “speak the mind.” Look at GMG Airlines; they mobilised large amounts through private placement. Their price discovery also very attractive and most importantly many people invested their life savings in them.

They came out with flowery picture though their information memorandum and now all the GMG planes have been grounded. I didn’t see many reports putting them on the dock. Nor have I seen any major investigation being launched against them.

Investors are losing confidence. Operators are feeling constrained. Regulators are feeling interfered. Portfolio investors are raising eyebrows. Analysts are not sure about the immediate future due to the brewing tension about political transition. Left hand is not talking to the right hand as far as regulatory interaction is concerned.

Bangladesh Bank in the past said they had nothing to do with capital market and now they are seen giving away Tk9bn from their profits to compensate small investors! Are we missing something?

I don’t know. What I know is we need to go beyond “vested interest” to fix our capital market on a sustainable basis.