The provision for non-party caretaker government (NCG) is under the High Court’s review to be reinstated. Article 58B and 58C of the constitution (before 15th amendment) describes the composition and appointment of advisers of the NCG. The primary purpose of forming a NCG is to hold a free, fair, neutral, inclusive and acceptable national election.
However, we should be mindful of the adverse consequences of the previous caretaker governments formed mainly following Clause-3, Clause-4 and Clause-6 of Article 58C. These clauses respectively direct to appoint a retired Chief Justice, retired Appellate Division Judge or the reigning president as the chief adviser (CA), who may be a partisan or dictator person. No need to restore them. Nevertheless, Clause-5 of Article 58C remained fully unexplored to date, maybe due lack of knowledge to apply it. Clause-5, on the contrary, suggests forming a NCG consulting with major political parties.
Clause-5 states:
“If no retired judge of the Appellate Division is available or willing to hold the office of Chief Adviser, the President shall, after consultation, as far as practicable, with the major political parties, appoint the Chief Adviser from among citizens of Bangladesh who are qualified to be appointed as Advisers under this article.”
Thus, Clause-5 provides an opportunity to appoint the CA from among truly non-partisan citizens of Bangladesh qualified to be advisers. Assuming the NCG system is reinstated, I developed a model of electing non-partisan neutral citizens qualified to be appointed as advisers following Clause-5 and Clause-7 of Article 58C and demonstrate how to form a non-partisan NCG supported by all political parties, without any dialog between political rivals.
Following Clause-5 and Clause-7, the president should take initiatives to
- appoint the CA;
- consult with major political parties, (avoiding direct consultation between the rival political opponents since such attempts failed in the past);
- choose the CA from among citizens of Bangladesh qualified to be advisers under the article (Clause-7),
- choose any qualified citizens (open to all, not specific profession)
Process of forming(NCG)
Step 1: Preparing a list of qualified non-partisans and interested citizens
Invite expressions of interest (EOI) from citizens with Clause-7 qualifications who declare non-partisanship. Each EOI should provide information sufficient to verify qualifications, capability and neutrality. Scrutinize submissions and finalize an eligibility list. For this purpose, a non-partisan is someone who was/is not a member of a party or its related organizations and has not received any known benefits from such parties/ organisations.
Step 2: Consultation with major political parties
For election purposes, parties can be grouped into two alliances: Ruling government parties’ alliance and the opposition parties’ alliance. To reduce conflict and expedite consultation, the president may give the eligibility list from Step 1 to each alliance separately and ask each to select/elect a “certain minimum number of candidates” so that enough names overlap to form the NCG.
Alliances may choose candidates through internal consultations or a democratic vote among parties within each alliance. Each alliance will submit the same number of names. Determining this “certain minimum number” correctly ensures overlapping of elected candidates chosen by both alliances.
I have developed a mathematical model to determine this critical minimum number. The number depends on the size of the NCG and the size of the candidates list. Detailing the model is unnecessary here; an example clarifies the method and shows its effectiveness.
Suppose 30 candidates constitute the final list obtained in Step 1. Suppose we must elect 12 candidates (for NCG) supported by both alliances from those 30. If the president asks both alliances to elect a minimum of 21 candidates each from the 30, by secret ballots, the two alliances together will make 42 selections. Because only 30 candidates exist, at least 12 must receive votes from both alliances. These overlapping names can be considered acceptable to all parties of the alliances and, therefore, to the nation.
Although each alliance votes for 21 candidates, only 12 need to be appointed to form the NCG. A maximum of 21 could be jointly supported if both alliances vote for the same set; selecting more creates no problem, because the desired 12 can be chosen from the jointly supported pool.
Step3: Electing the CA
After the election of 12 non-partisan neutral persons, choosing the NCG CA is straightforward. Two easy options exist:
- a) The president appoints one of the 12 as CA
- b) The 12 advise the president through a preferential ranking, in secret ballots, where each ranks themself and the other candidates by perceived merit. Whoever first reaches seven votes, counting from higher ranks downward, is placed first, and so on. The President may then choose one candidate as CA from those ranked 1-3.
The CA will then select advisers from the remaining 11. I prefer the latter option for more transparency and greater acceptability.
Thus, it is feasible to elect non-party advisers supported by both political alliances without any dialogue/discussion between rival alliances and without using the chief justice, judges or president.
Dr Abu Taher Mollik is a Researcher and an Adjunct Associate Professor at University of Canberra, Australia.