Bangladesh is a corrupt country -- or, perhaps, to soften the blow a little, there's a lot of corruption in the country called Bangladesh. One recent report -- which includes such things as tax evasion, which is a possibly slightly different issue -- is as much as $15 billion a year under the previous administration. Apparently the corruption rating for Bangladesh is only just better than that of Afghanistan.
This is vile, of course it is. It is also wildly wasteful. To an economist wasteful is also vile but not so much for those ethical reasons. Rather, because waste itself is vile -- what could be done to improve the lives of people gets wasted instead. Lives are not made better and that, in itself, is unethical.
There are two different ways in which this waste works. Obviously, our very definition of corruption in government is that contracts, privileges, licences, and permits are granted to those who are not the best people to have them.
This might be done to gain political support, might be done in return for mere cash payments. But if things are being done by the people who are not the most efficient -- because, instead, everything goes to those who pay -- then there's a loss there.
We get less done for whatever resources are used simply because we are lacking efficiency.
But a far larger loss is that if a system is corrupt in this manner then there will be many attempting to gain that access to government-distributed privileges. More effort, collectively, will go into trying to gain the privileges than they are actually worth in fact. Sure, sure, that licence will be worth the necessary payment to the person who actually gets it. But the many people who expend resources trying -- but failing -- to get it will have wasted all their efforts and even money. The collective loss can be -- and corrupt markets will usually make it so -- more than the individual and final gain.
That is, we have to think not just of the economic loss of efficiency from the licence, the activity being done by the inefficient. But also the loss of everyone else who was trying to gain that same privilege.
We would clearly also like to stop this system. We would be richer through no great effort in fact. Merely reducing the waste is what is called a pure economic gain. We need to have no more resources -- no more capital, raw materials, labour -- and yet gain more output simply by not wasting what we have.
So, yes, we'd like to have less corruption, obviously. But note what is the larger of the costs of corruption -- the pursuit of favours. It's not the loss from the special licences being paid for that is so expensive. It's all the work and effort being put into maybe getting the special favours that is.
The answer, therefore, is not to have special favours which can be granted. Simply stop using the government, or bureaucracy, to decide who may do what on what terms and circumstances. Yes, of course, we still need to have laws -- don't poison people and all that. But we simply have the one set of laws, no exceptions, no licences, no permissions. If you're obeying the law then good luck to you and get on with it.
The way to beat the corruption of business buying governments is to make sure that it's not worth business buying governments. After all, who would bother to pay politicians if they didn't have to?
That is, to stop corruption just make politics valueless.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institution in London.