Not broke, just busy

The United Nations has one of those chin-stroking reports out. You know the sort of thing, very important people have thought deeply about this and entirely missed the point. 

 

The core point is that people are not having as many children as they would like to have. Well, yes, every survey that has ever been done shows that the average number of desired children (they usually only ask women) is one more than actually had. 

 

After all, who wouldn't want to have another babe in arms, another set of grandchildren to spoil. But, there are costs and so the desire isn't fully fulfilled. How unlike the rest of life that is.

 

But then the UN goes seriously wrong. For they then start talking about how it's the dreadful lack of money that produces these low -- lower -- birth and fertility rates. Which is nonsense, something we can prove with a very simple test. 

 

It’s not about the money 

 

It is the richer nations, societies, which have lower birth rates than the poorer. So it isn't -- cannot be -- that being poorer reduces birth rates. Don't forget, in any contest between a theory and reality it is always reality that wins. 

 

There's a lovely word game that can be played -- “Two Things.” The economist Glenn Whitman describes any profession or activity in just the two things. So, boxing is “hit and don't get hit.” Civil engineering is “water plus dirt is mud. There is always mud.” Economics is “incentives matter. Opportunity costs.” The thing that we are dealing with here about fertility rates is that second part of economics.

 

The basic insight is obvious -- as is true of so much economics. If we do this thing here, then we cannot also do this other thing over there. We've used our resources, our time, and our effort to do one of the two and have none left over to do both. The cost of doing one thing is the other thing that we do not do -- the opportunity cost. 

 

There are opportunity costs to everything. Simply because choosing this one thing to do means not doing all sorts of other things. 

 

This is important. As a society becomes richer then the number of things that can be done with a life becomes larger. Therefore the number of times any specific thing is done with a life becomes smaller. Because the costs of doing any one thing becomes higher -- there are more things to do in life. 

 

Our most basic observation about human beings is that they do less of things that are more expensive, more of those that are cheaper. 

 

Therefore, as we get richer as a society, the fertility rate will fall. Because having children -- the raising of them more than the having of them -- is not consistent with the many of the things that people would like to do with their lives. More choices means any one choice is taken less often.

 

The UN report is taking the fall in the fertility rate as being evidence of poverty. That it's not possible to have children because there's not the financial backing to do so. But the fall in the fertility rate is evidence of wealth, not poverty. There are more things we can do therefore we have fewer children -- or as it actually works out, less of us have fewer children.

 

Now this specific mistake isn't what wholly annoys me. We can all be wrong on certain specifics after all. But what has me frothing with rage is that the international bureaucracy -- the nomenklatura, the apparatchiks of the global system -- are always like this. They hold to fashionable beliefs without doing that most basic testing against reality.

 

How can anyone expert note that fertility rates are lowest in rich places and then assume that low fertility is a product of poverty? What they do is why we should pay these international organizations no attention, give them no mind. If they cannot even get the most basic observations right then why should we take note of their blatherings in the slightest?

 

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.