Asking the wrong question

Everywhere I go, the burning question that is on everyone’s lips is: Will there be an election? The corollary question is always: How do we get to free and fair elections, participated in by all the parties?

The unspoken assumption is that elections are the be-all and end-all of our democratic aspirations, and that if we are able to hold elections that everything will then turn out fine.

We are thus now being treated to a never-ending cycle of round-table discussions and seminars and meetings and closed-door consultations, to say nothing of articles, essays, papers, and op-eds, in which the great and the good put their eminent heads together to try to cobble together some formula that will be acceptable to all relevant sides.

How do we convince the AL to reinstate the caretaker government? How do we convince the BNP to take part in elections under the current government? What kind of compromise solution might be acceptable to both sides? What does the constitution say?

I’m sorry to have to play the spoiler here, but the sad fact of the matter is that, as things stand right now, elections will do nothing to resolve the problems that the country is facing, and that obsessing on how we get there is to ask the wrong question.

The right question (and one that we are not spending nearly enough time thinking about) to ask is: What will happen after an election?

Let us leave aside the obstacles to a free and fair election for the time being, and focus for a moment on a best-case scenario post-elections.

There can only be three possible outcomes: either the AL retains power, the BNP comes to power, or there is a hung parliament.

Within these three broad outlines there may be a number of sub-combinations and permutations, but, as things stand today, these three outcomes represent the sum total of all possibilities post-election.

What happens if the AL retains power? If the AL retains power, then they will certainly finish the job that they have started. The war crimes trials will be brought to a conclusion, and the guilty will be hanged. The five-year campaign to crush the BNP will be renewed. The BNP and its allies, most notably the Jamaat, are hardly likely to meekly sit still and take it. I fear that a second AL term could set off a serious cycle of violence and counter-violence.

Of course, if the BNP comes to power, they will do the same thing in reverse. We have already seen in 2001 what the party is capable of in the first flush of electoral victory, and after the indignities it has suffered over the past 7 years, do not expect it to be magnanimous. What a resurgent Jamaat might do, can only be imagined.

And a hung parliament will differ from the above two scenarios only in that neither side will have the upper hand. But the violence we can expect as they duke it out on the streets to see who wants it more will be no less.

The bottom line is without some kind of credible post-election non-aggression pact on the part of the major political players, then elections solve nothing. What we have seen over their past two terms in office is the breaking down of the compact of co-existence between the two sides. Neither side can co-exist with the other any more, and neither side evens bothers to pretend any more, either.

All well-meaning efforts to bring the two sides to the table when it comes to creating an acceptable playing field for the elections are, I fear, wildly optimistic and unrealistic, given the mind-set and imperatives of the parties’ respective leaderships. But, more to the point, they are moot.

It is critical that we focus on the right question. It is only when we acknowledge and accept that the post-election scenario is fraught with danger and uncertainty, and that pretending that everything will magically sort itself out in the wake of a good election (however we choose to define one) is seriously short-sighted, that we can focus on a possible solution.

And don’t let anyone tell you that there is no solution. There are always solutions, and in this case, there are solutions that would do no violence either to the constitution or to our democracy, and that would protect the rights and interests of all parties concerned, including, crucially, those of the Bangladeshi people.

But in order to get to a workable solution, we need to acknowledge the fact that pushing through elections without paying attention to what happens in their aftermath will solve nothing.

To get the right answer, we need to ask the right question.