Whether selling physical pleasure is morally right or wrong is always a very delicate debate. Prostitution has been around since the beginning of mankind, so it is prudent to concede that the profession has some social requirements. Otherwise, it would have withered away.
Naturally, when morality and ethics are brought into the equation, the profession of a sex worker draws flak. However, before taking a moral high-ground, society must also remember that values and principles are secondary in politics and other fields in Bangladesh.
Anyway, the objective here is not to glorify the oldest profession in the world, but to dissect the recent incident where a brothel in Madaripur was stormed and the women working and residing in it were forced to leave.
Reportedly, a section of conscious activists deemed this deed is the purging of a social malady. They believed that since under-age girls were being forced to become sex workers in the brothel, its dismantling would offer them a chance to go home and find a new life. Obviously, this sounds very noble but one needs to elaborate on the “going home” and the “new life” aspects.
Most young girls who work as sex workers in brothels were born there and have known the community of sex workers as their only surrounding. When, all of a sudden, they find themselves in the open without their familiar surroundings, how will they survive without other prospects and skills?
This is not to say that young girls from elsewhere are not trafficked or sold to brothels clearly these acts are condemnable beyond question but summarily demolishing a pattern of life, for which society creates a demand no matter how debauched it may seem to the puritans, is no solution.
The impact of the closure of the Taanbazar brothel in Narayanganj a few years ago needs to be remembered. After its multi-storied premises were shut, most occupants did not go back to normal life. Instead, they became floating sex workers, and were placed in even more danger by becoming more likely to indulge in more unsafe/reckless sexual behaviour.
If the moral brigade in Madaripur had been so concerned about the welfare of women they would have supported their crackdown by pre-arranged rehabilitation programmes and work opportunities. However, that did not happen and may not have even been considered.
Forcing under-age girls to engage in paid sex is unquestionably reprehensible. However, it is wise to keep in mind that simply driving young women on to the streets, without any clear guidance as to what they may do to earn a living, can never be an answer. Puzzlingly, the shipping minister is reported to have said that the girls will now be rehabilitated. Really! Where, how and by whom?
As far as we know, the girls fled the brothel and no NGOs helped them train for a respectable life.
In a perfect world women should not be selling sex but let’s shed that utopian dream and admit that this world is far from perfect. There are no black and white solutions to anything, least of all prostitution.
Coming to the much used term of “sin,” when politicians make promises and then renege on them, lying blatantly to the public, moral armies such as those at Madaripur do not raise pandemonium about how the flames of hell are engulfing us; nor do they protest when society becomes hostage to bribery, nepotism and exploitation of the masses.
Strangely, all their revulsion is directed against “anti-social” acts, which, from a neutral angle, are comparatively more transparent because with the exchange of money, both parties part ways with each other’s goals fulfilled.
Now the debate about whether brothels should be allowed or not is indeed complex; this writer observes that no clear conclusion and solution has been reached on this issue throughout human history.
So we need not piety but practicality. As long as there is civilisation, commercial sex will exist, if not as a recognised social sector then as a shadow. The bottom line is, prostitution will be there. To ensure that children are not introduced to the trade, social workers and NGOs must be permitted free access to the brothels.
Sex workers without an address pose far more threat to social welfare because they cannot be given counselling on safe sex, usage of condoms and risks from STDs and Aids. Their interactions with clients are more likely to fall within the high risk category. This practical factor must be borne in mind when considering this issue.
Furthermore, one can observe much hypocrisy surrounding this crusade to cleanse society, which targets poorer women in low cost establishments providing sexual gratification, while their five star equivalents are protected by law enforcers.
To end, here is the reality for you: a man can walk into a top hotel, flash a credit card, hire a room and pick up an escort girl from the bar for some wild moments. Onlookers may disapprove but never protest; on the contrary they can walk out feeling like Don Juan. Like Oscar Wilde said: “Beautiful sins like beautiful things are the privilege of the rich!”