“Hang the Rapist” has become the most common slogan in response to the recent surge in rape cases, especially after the rape of an 8-year-old girl in Magura. While many demand the death penalty, others argue that the certainty of punishment is more important than its severity. Ensuring the certainty of conviction and adopting a victim-centred approach are undoubtedly crucial. However, it is often questioned why punishment should not be severe and why it must necessarily remain ‘civilized’? The increasing public demand for capital punishment reflects this retributive sentiment, underpinned by multiple socio-cultural and contextual factors that warrant careful consideration.
Rape is one of the gravest crimes and is recognized as a felony in most countries. At least 31 countries around the world still retain the death penalty for rape. Bangladesh has also introduced the death penalty for rape, which has been widely criticized but is also rarely enforced. It is worth noting that a comprehensive perspective must be adopted before concluding on the effectiveness of the death penalty for rape, as rigidly adhering to abolitionist views appears impractical given the gravity of the crime and the contextual realities.
One of the common abolitionist arguments is that "a woman's life is not solely her honour," but is our society truly ready to accept this notion? In reality, sexual offenses against women are often seen as a loss of honour -- an irreversible stigma, as if her life has ended. If society does not evolve, laws based on this notion in the name of modernity will hold little practical meaning and will become irrelevant over time. In our context, rape destroys a life, if not physically, then mentally, emotionally, and socially.
The brutality enacted on Asiya and her desperate struggle to survive before her eventual death have been visible to the whole nation. The victim was raped, and to cover up the crime, the perpetrators attempted to kill her. She suffered unbearably for seven days in the hospital, trembling in agony, and kept on life support. On the morning of her death, she went through two episodes of cardiac arrest, her heart stopped beating twice. She endured such intense suffering that it felt like she had died multiple times before her death.
Even if she had survived, where was her right to live with dignity? Could she ever return to a normal life? The trauma she endured, the brutal assault on her body and soul, can it ever be fully repaired? Her name, her photo -- they have already been etched into the memories of millions. Even if she had survived, there would still have been a liminal space between life and death, a hollow existence suspended between pain and survival.
Another frequently cited argument is that the death penalty may encourage perpetrators to kill their victims to eliminate evidence. Does this mean we should glorify mere survival, with lifelong physical injuries, psychological trauma, and social stigma? A victim should feel fortunate simply because the rapist spared her life? Such reasoning ignores a fundamental truth that it was her life and her right to live it with dignity, not as a mercy granted by her assailant.
Ideally, punishments should be restorative and civilized. However, how can a Westernized punishment system function in a society that lacks contextual and resourceful arrangements, where people's thoughts and attitudes remain rooted in outdated mindsets? In this society, most girls experience sexual harassment from childhood, often by their closest relatives, while the concepts of consent and sex education barely exist. Victims are shamelessly blamed in public, and their clothing is scrutinized more than the crime itself. Even staying behind closed doors does not protect a woman from rape, and victims often have to die to prove their suffering.
How can we pretend to be advanced enough to impose restorative punishment for such brutal crimes? Instead, the state machinery reacts only when people take to the streets, and rapists are often granted bail rather than facing consequences. These harsh contextual realities and the lack of confidence in the justice system drive more people to demand the death penalty for rape.
Critics argue that popular sentiment cannot always justify inhumane punishment, but if laws are meant to reflect society's will, why shouldn't rape laws mirror it? Countries such as the US, Canada, Russia, Israel, France, and Norway -- often cited as abolitionists -- do not serve as our legislative role models due to cultural, historical, and social differences. In contrast, countries like India, Pakistan, Iran, and North Korea retain the death penaltyfor rape, which should not be blindly followed either. According to the theory of functionalism, legal transplantation from other countries is acceptable if the laws function effectively and produce comparable outcomes in similar cultural contexts. Meanwhile, expressivism and legal realism emphasize that laws should express the values of the society they govern and align with practical realities.
Therefore, our punishment system should not simply “copy-paste” from foreign legal frameworks, but instead critically assess their relevance and rationality within our own societal perspective.
While empirical data on deterrence remains mixed, the fear of the death penalty still acts as one of the effective deterrents, especially in countries with weak justice systems and high crime rates. Alongside the certainty of conviction, exemplary punishment may serve as one of the most effective tools to maintain order and deter the escalation of crimes. However, that does not exempt the state from taking positive steps toward restorative justice, nor does it shift the focus away from the victim.
Jeba Mobashwira is a postgraduate student of law.