A Moody's downgrade is a terrible thing, right? If they change their outlook on the Bangladeshi banking system from stable to negative we should all run shrieking in the streets and pull our money into cash and weep for the terrors to come?
These credit ratings agencies -- Moody's, Fitch, S&P -- are important for companies as they determine the rate at which they can borrow money. For sectors and countries the reports are more like something for bankers to chat about over their tea. The fun part of those chats being pulling out from the rather bland language the important things that are really being said.
So it is here. Yes, inflation is expected to be a little higher, growth a little lower, this is not “be happy” trading times for the banks. Anyone who was already looking at the Bangladeshi economy would have noted the inflation, growth, changes, and assumed this about the banks anyway. These sectoral -- as opposed to individual company -- reports are usually a restatement of the prevailing wisdom.
The fun part to be pulled out is something this column has been saying ever since it started getting on a decade back. The state-owned banks are the problem in the Bangladeshi banking system. They should be closed, or sold off to whoever will have them.
Moody's is far too polite to state this quite the way I will, but here's the information “system-wide NPL ratio had surged to 17% from 9% just nine months earlier. State-owned banks remain particularly vulnerable, with an average capital-to-risk-weighted-assets ratio of -2.5% as of September 2024, well below the private sector average of 9.4%.”
NPL is non-performing loans. People who have borrowed money but are not paying it back. Capital ratio is how much of its own money does the bank have to cover the losses from people who borrow money and then don't pay it back.
The NPL problem is concentrated in the state-owned banks. The state-owned banks are also the ones that don't have enough of that capital put aside to cover the losses from those people who aren't paying their loans back. This is all a problem of those state-owned banks.
Why?
Why do governments and political parties like state-owned banks? Because, as they actually say, there are people who commercial, private, banks will not lend money to. Therefore there should be a system that lends money to those who political parties think should be able to borrow money. And, as these things work out, those that political parties think should be able to borrow money and commercial banks spending their own money think should not be able to borrow money tend to be those who will not, or do not, repay the loans.
The entire idea of state-owned banks is to lend money to people less likely to repay their loans
No, this is not just about the families of ministers even as we know there are accusations of that floating around. The entire point of government owned banks is to have political direction of who can borrow money. We'd not need government owned banks if all those people were credit worthy by the standards of private sector banking. The entire idea is to lend money to those less likely to repay their loans.
Which is why the problems with non-performing loans are concentrated in the state-owned banks. They exist precisely and exactly to make this happen. Which is, obviously enough, why we shouldn't have them.
No, this is not a problem of just the last and most recently departed government. Clearly, we can all shout that they did this and some of that shouting might even be right. The very existence of such a system is expressly designed to allow this to happen. Even if a little less to friends and relations than might have happened.
As I've said before. Sell them all and if no one wants to buy them shut them down. The entire idea of state-owned banks is to lend money to people less likely to repay their loans. Sometimes that's corruption, sometimes it's politics and always it's a waste of our money. So, let's not do it.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.