A number of decades back I was there as the Soviet Union fell to pieces. In fact, I was editing pieces in a Russian economics magazine as this happened -- and there's one little comment about the move to free market food prices that still resonates.
Russians decorate eggs -- normal chicken eggs, not the American idea of the Easter Bunny delivering chocolate ones -- for Easter. So, food prices had just been freed from seven decades of controls and in that run up to Easter egg prices had risen. At which point a colleague interviewed a babushka (a Russian Granny) who said “Why are they raising prices just as everyone needs eggs?”
She wouldn't understand the correct answer, nor in fact had those who had been running the Soviet Union those seven decades. Higher demand means higher prices, that's just how the world works. Attempts to make that not true don't work.
Which brings us to the usual complaints that food prices are rising just before Ramadan. How could this be true? Because the demand for food -- good food -- rises at this time of the year therefore prices rise. Just as with eggs at the Orthodox Christian Easter.
There is, however, one little joy in this newspaper's commentary on the event this time around: “Traders claim that the government is levying Tk136 in taxes on every Tk100 worth of imported fruit, preventing them from reducing prices. As a result, domestic fruit prices have also increased.”
The thing we have to understand is that raising the price of domestic fruit is the very aim of having taxes on the import of foreign fruit. That's the whole point and purpose of it.
This is, in fact, the point and purpose of any import tariffs (taxes on imports) or limitations upon imports or quotas or permissions or licenses. This is also why we should not have such things.
The aim of our having an economy -- heck, a civilization -- is that we all get to live the best lives possible. Which means that the things we want should be cheap. Even, that the things that we want should be getting cheaper -- then we can have more and our lives are better.
Raising the price of domestic fruit is the very aim of having taxes on the import of foreign fruit
People who produce things are not so keen on this. They'd prefer that we should have to pay more -- to them -- and so they wax fat off the higher prices we have to pay.
Tariffs, trade restrictions, are exactly this. Foreigners can't be allowed to sell their lovely produce, nice and cheap, because this lowers the price that the domestic producers can sell it at. Domestic producers -- and their profits -- are very against this idea. So, that political activity to save their profits by action, restrictions, and taxes against that dastardly foreigner.
Which means that the “as a result” domestic fruit prices are higher is true but not quite enough. The domestic fruit growers have gained enough political power to insist that there should be taxes on foreign fruit. The aim being that this will therefore increase domestic fruit prices. This will mean higher profits for domestic fruit producers -- those higher profits coming out of our pockets or, of course, in our not having as much fruit as we'd like.
The whole game of trade restrictions is so that we, us out here, have to pay more. More then goes to the producers, the capitalists, here at home.
This is an odd idea. We should be poorer so that they should be richer? And the thing is, no really, this is the entire argument in favour of trade restrictions, trade tariffs, licenses, quotas, and all the rest. It really is all about pushing up the prices we must pay on our buying in order to increase the profits of those who produce.
Maybe we should stop agreeing to do that?
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.