Alms for the poor?

There was a lovely time in Britain, back in that almost mythical past, when political scandals were about who had been having sex with whom. One such lady of negotiable affection -- a euphemism, you understand -- was asked, at a trial, why the cabinet minister who had been provably bedding her had said that he didn't know her at all. “Well, he would, wouldn't he?” This is now known as The Mandy Rice Davis Statement, given that she was Mandy Rice Davis.  

 

In a certain part of British thinking, this MRDS has become a litmus test of what someone is saying. It is, after all, true that not all cabinet ministers know all ladies of the night. Not all of them. Either way not all of them. It is, though, worth weighting such a statement with a certain level of skepticism. 

 

At which point we're told by the World Bank interim director for Bangladesh that mere cash for the poor isn't quite the thing. It is “cash plus,” which is “combine cash transfers with complementary interventions to address the root causes of poverty and empower individuals, leading to impactful poverty reduction.“ And, well, yes.

 

Consider what someone at the World Bank does: They advise upon the political actions which should be undertaken to increase the general wealth of the country, reduce the poverty suffered by those within it. That is great, admirable even. But of course no one really does want to destroy their own job and comfortable lifestyle by advising on a simple solution to the problem they make their living advising upon. 

 

And the thing is that cash, even without the plus, does in fact reduce poverty. If a poor person has more cash then they are less poor than they were before. This is axiomatic, not something arguable. Well, ok, maybe it is true that more than just cash will increase the amount of ‘not poor.” Conceptually this could be true, clearly. 

 

This is also something that appears not to be true. The important word here is “agency.” This is also the basic root of the liberal, free market view of the world. We know what improves our lives -- or what would -- better than anyone else. We thus value that agency, that ability, to do that thing that improves our lives. Not what someone else thinks will improve it, what we, ourselves, looking at our desires and wants, think will. 

 

This applies -- very strongly -- to bureaucrats in offices who will spend money we could have had on what they think will improve our lives. 

 

Two little data points on this. The US Census runs the reports and numbers on the American welfare state. Free medical care to the poor, subsidies for rent, there is a list 180 different programs long. Even the US Census, the people keeping tabs on this, say that the value, as perceived by the recipients, is less than if we just gave them the money instead. The poor would consider themselves richer -- and it is the poors' opinion that matters -- if they didn't have the “plus” and instead just got the cash. A big research program in India -- so, among those poorer than Bangladeshi farmers -- found the same result. Giving people cash produced more value than giving them things.

 

The reason? Agency. With cash people can decide for themselves what makes their lives richer. If they're given things -- food, housing, and even services such as health care or education -- then they cannot pick and choose among what benefits them, by their understanding, the most. Give them what bureaucrats think they should have and they're poorer than if we just sent them the same amount of cash. Because of this agency. 

 

Humans value being able to make their own decisions about life. So, if we want to alleviate poverty we have two things to do: One is to just grow the economy so there's more of everything for everyone. The other is, well, we want to reduce poverty then give poor people more cash.

 

On the other hand, we have the World Bank wallahs insisting on “cash plus.” People like the World Bank wallahs deciding what poor people should be given, is better. Well, they would say that, wouldn't they?    

 

 

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.