That the government is increasing VAT -- not just the rate on some things, but what it applies to -- is causing some pushback. The real lesson from this is that statement from Thomas Sowell -- there are no solutions, only trade offs.
The problem here is that VAT falls more heavily on the poorer in society. The rich save some of their income, savings do not pay VAT, so the tax is regressive. The poor pay a higher portion of their income in this tax than the rich.
Now, sure, we can control that by removing VAT from things that are really essential -- rice, food generally, and so on. But it's still true. A VAT hits the poor harder than the rich. That's not good, it hits hard against our general understanding of what's fair. In more formal terms, it breaches equity.
On the other hand, VAT is a very efficient method of gaining tax revenue. One of the things about taxation is that there always is this tension between equity and efficiency. What's fair and what gets the cash rolling in at the lowest cost?
The efficiency, the cost, we're talking about here is not how many inspectors we've got to hire to collect the money. We're talking about a wider meaning of “efficient” here.
Just by taxing we stop some economic activity happening. This is just what happens as prices change. Sometimes we do this deliberately -- taxes on tobacco or alcohol are deliberately set to reduce the amount of consumption.
How much economic activity doesn't happen because of the tax is called the deadweight. It's lovely to be able to spend the money raised from the tax and it's even possible that the spending will increase growth. But the taxation, just as tax, kills some economic activity simply and merely by its existence -- the deadweight.
We also know that different forms of taxation have different deadweights. Land taxes the lowest, then consumption (like a VAT or sales tax), then upon income, then capital and corporate, then transactions taxes. This is not the result of some particular form of economics, isn't backed by a particular political view. This is simply an observation of the world.
One of the things about taxation is that there always is this tension between equity and efficiency. What's fair and what gets the cash rolling in at the lowest cost?
So, we face this trade off. We'd like our taxation system to be fair. Even Adam Smith said that the richer should pay “more than in proportion” to their higher incomes. Or, as we can also put it, the rich should pay for society. Seems fair to me. But it's also true that those taxes that weigh more heavily upon the rich -- capital, wealth, corporate -- taxes destroy more economic activity than those that weigh more heavily upon the poorer -- like a VAT.
There is no solution to this. It's a trade off. Equity and efficiency operate, often enough, in different directions when discussing tax.
Which is the point at which economics ends. For economics does not tell us which trade off we should make. Only -- if done well, obviously -- what those are. But what economics cannot tell us is the values we, as individuals, place on each of the costs, each of the benefits. That's over in philosophy, morals, possibly even ethics. As those differ for each of us, we then have to come up with some generally agreed average -- which is the realm of politics.
Now, for me, my dodge around this is simply to insist that we have a very small state. If we have little government then and therefore we can have low taxation and this battle between equity and efficiency becomes one of those angels on pinheads arguments, a battle between the primacy of the louse and the flea. Others have different solutions.
But the fact remains. Fair taxes and efficient taxes are not the same thing. So, we have a trade off we need to make.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.