It's very fashionable to be in favour of the stakeholder economy. This is the idea that companies should think about more than just their profits. They should think about and act so as to be nice to the environment, to their employees, and to society more generally. This is then backed up by an insistence that companies that do this will make higher profits.
One observation is that this isn't necessarily true. Much the same has been said about DEI -- diversity, inclusion, and equity -- in the US economy. Those previously oppressed groups must be privileged now. That might even be true, perhaps morally they should. But the assertion that those who do this will make greater profits turns out to be untrue.
So too affirmative action. So too -- well, we can compile a long list of things that various thinkers have said that companies should do. All backed by that joint insistence that not only is it good for society, it increases profits too.
The other, and far more important, observation is that if these things do increase profits then they'll be done by companies that think only about their profits. So there's no need to urge them to do these things therefore. And, obviously, absolutely no need to legislate to make sure they do these things. They're interested in what makes them more money. You've just told them that this will make them more money. So, they're going to do it.
Well, they're going to try it at least. There are many things which are said to increase profits -- from my time as a salesman I recall telling people that buying from me will make them money. (No, really, it will.) Near all of these claims will be tried by someone, at some time, and we all find out whether the claim is true by putting it to that market test.
Now this is not to say that companies, employers, those who would get rich, should actively go out to trash the environment. Or be mean to their employees, or vile to society more generally. It is, instead, to insist that we've already got a method of testing these claims.
We really don't have to tempt capitalists into increasing their profits
Yes, of course research into whether these things are true -- or not -- is interesting and useful. So too is the dissemination of the information about the claimed effects of this or that policy. But as I say, we have a method of testing the real world effect here. People will try the new thing, whatever it is. Those things which really do improve profits will be adopted. Those things that don't, won't.
These things will be tried out -- adopted if they work -- not because of any insistence that they should be. Rather, because it really is true that companies, capitalists, employers, are trying to increase their own profits. So, things that increase profits will be done. Those that don't, won't.
To repeat, we already have our testing system, our sorting mechanism.
Adam Smith did tell us all this a quarter of a millennium ago: “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own self-interest. We address ourselves not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities, but of their advantages.”
Something that is to their advantage is something they'll do.
This is true of the stakeholder economy just as it is about anything else we might claim is a good idea. If our claim is indeed that this will increase profits then all we've got to do is tell the capitalists this. For, if it's true, then they'll do it.
The other, and perhaps simpler, way of putting this is that we really don't have to tempt capitalists into increasing their profits. We might well find ways of increasing those profits. We might even have to tell the capitalists as they've not thought of it yet. But we've really not got to force them into doing it once the proof is in. Because the capitalists are interested in the profits, their own self-interest.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.