Now that we're in the new year -- by my calendar at least, with some others it's difficult to work out which century, let alone year, they're in -- a little insistence on what it is that we really need to be considering when we discuss economics, the economy.
This is not for me to get up on my old high horse and insist that classical liberalism -- even neoliberalism -- is where it's useful. Rather, let's start right at the beginning. Let's not talk about policy, or politics, or the little details of either. Instead, what's the one big, grand, task in front of us?
We'd like all of us to be as rich as possible. We can argue over what rich means, of course. Perhaps it isn't mere physical possessions after all. But, given the constraints of the real world around us we'd like all to be living as well as is possible. Seems, to me at least, to be a reasonable enough ambition. At which point, if I can just get that little advertisement in for neoliberalism, use markets. Try everything and then do more of what works. Less of what doesn't and that's how we'll get there.
But leave such propaganda to one side. We need to think about the real basics here. If we're all to live well then what is it that we need to get rid of?
Which is how we should, perhaps, think about this report from the International Food Policy Research Institute. Which discusses the -- entirely welcome -- end of the zamindari system and then thinks that there are still problems to solve. Which, no doubt, there are. But it fails to even mention the real and basic problem here. We want there to be no small farmers. Absolutely no one at all trying to make a living off a hectare or two of land.
This is difficult for some to understand. The small farmer, the backbone of the nation. And in Bangladesh right now that does provide about 40% of the jobs, the livings, of the population. But we've a terrible problem here. Those livings, from small plots of land, are always going to be very poor livings.
Think, for a moment. Say that the farm is less than a hectare (one report has near 90% of farms at less than this size). Or, just for convenience, say it is one hectare. 150 katha, perhaps. That's actually a medium, not small, sized farm but let's run with it as our example.
The problem with peasant farming is that peasant farmers have to live like peasants, on the income of peasants
So, the income available to any farmer is the value of the output of one hectare. That's it, it cannot be any higher than that. Sure, it's possible to change what that output is by moving from rice to horticulture. Or to increase the amount retained by the farmer by lowering input costs.
But the gross income, the possible top level income, is that value of what can be grown on one hectare. Which is, by current Bangladeshi rural incomes, pretty good. But by the standards of a rich country it's appalling.
We've already said that we want to increase living standards. Which means that we need to reduce the number of people limited to the income possible from one hectare.
What we actually desire, therefore, is that all those small farms be consolidated into large farms. The remaining farmers then have incomes defined by the possible income from 50 or 500 hectares.
Everyone else has gone off to do something else. Work in factories, or offices where more value can be added to their labour and therefore more can and will be paid to them.
That is, to make the world a better, richer, place we do not want to make small farmers better off. We wish to eliminate small farmers. Of course, we don't want to do that the way some tried – Stalin's treatment of the kulaks is not something to repeat. But it is still true.
We do not desire, at all, to preserve small farms. We wish to eliminate them. For, and this is to switch to the English meaning of the word, the problem with peasant farming is that peasant farmers have to live like peasants, on the income of peasants. Given that peasant incomes, the gross and vile poverty of the peasant lifestyle, are what we wish to destroy by all getting richer then, and therefore, peasant farming is the thing we want to kill off.
Now, if international organizations like the IFPRI started to say things like that then I could get behind them.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.