THE LAST WORD

Greed for good

So the Cop 29 deal wasn't what certain people wanted. Isn't that a shame. That's also not how to judge the Cop 29 deal -- after all, you and I would also like some free money, but we tend not to get it too. 

The initial demand was that there should be $1.3 trillion of climate finance available to the poorer nations. We can, for the purpose of the argument here, just accept that number. The complaint is now that the poor nations are being offered only $300 billion which is, as the mathematically inclined will note, rather less. But the two numbers are not counting the same thing which is where the, to put this delicately, misleading is happening. 

The $1.3tn is the total amount that is necessary -- so it is said -- for the poor countries to be able to deal with climate change. The $300bn is the amount that the rich countries are going to send from their taxpayers to the governments of the poor countries. These are, indeed, different things. 

Fortunately, just before the Cop meeting we had a report out from the High Level Commission on whatever it calls itself. Just another grouping of people calling themselves something. But this group included Nick Stern. Who, as we will all recall, wrote the Stern Review -- the very economic analysis which underpins the basic idea that we should be doing something about climate change. He's even got some ideas about what we should be doing. 

Now his numbers were slightly different here. $1tn in total, $250bn that needs to come from rich world governments directly. But those are close enough that we can see they're describing the same things. And Stern then went on to point out something useful. 

The capitalists will happily provide $500bn of that. As an example, say solar power. As we're endlessly told this is now cheaper than fossil fuel plants. It's also true that a growing economy will require more energy. Ok -- but does that mean that rich world taxpayers should build all the solar plants in poor countries? No, not really, not at all in fact. 

We might have views about the Adani group of companies, but Adani Solar seems to be doing well enough. A capitalist company, raising capital the usual way, to build solar plants. Why do the taxpayers of the US, or UK, have to pay for those power plants? The answer is they don't. Just the normal interplay of investment in markets will lead to those plants being built. We don't need to do anything else -- we've already done it by making solar power cheap. 

We can extend this idea out across the economy and Nick Stern does so. There are things to be done which are just good investments anyway. So, as good investments they'll be invested in. There's no reason for, no argument in favour of, subsidy. Well, other than that folk always like something for free. 

The next $250 billion will come from the usual development funding sources. The World Bank, the Asian Development Bank and so on. They're not going away, they'll continue to raise and invest money. 

In Stern's numbers it's only that last $250bn that needs to be subsidized. Needs to be taking money off rich-world taxpayers to give to poor-world governments. That's also pretty close to the $300bn that has actually been promised. 

So the Cop 29 deal really isn't as bad as people are whining about. Even if $1.3tn is needed, that's not at all the same as insisting that all of that needs to be a gift. There might well be some amount of that which does need to be a gift -- and the amount of the gift promised seems to be about that amount that needs to be a gift. 

The thing we all need to remember. Government is not the only source of development money. Even about something as difficult as climate change there's a lot that will be done just by the normal greed of capitalists. Government only needs to get involved in the bits that can;t be solved by those other means. Which is the result Cop 29 ended up with. Which isn't, you know, a bad thing. 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.