Bangladesh has always faced challenges with regard to its law enforcement, and the inevitable need for police reform. The nexus between the police force and political parties is decadent to the principles of justice and fairness, calling for an autonomous policing system that should be equipped with transparency, accountability, and professionalism to preserve the critical need for actual rule of law along with proper maintenance of human rights, public order, and security.
Historically speaking, the functioning of a police force under state mechanisms has time and again fallen short of the general masses’ expectations. It has come to a point, where police conduct is perceived to be at a stand still in terms of reform. The necessity comes down to political courage and a firm will to move forward towards the construction of a people’s police.
If we trace back our footsteps to the oldest yet still prevalent primary law, the Police Act of 1861, implemented during the British colonial era, the police force was (and perhaps still is) a structured instrument of state control rather than protection.
Unfortunately, despite five decades of independence, the core tenets of this law have remained unchanged, and many legal ambiguities within the act provide opportunity for political interference in policing structures and operations. This has also allowed the abuse of police power by ruling parties to consolidate power and enforce partisan agendas.
While many studies have critiqued and asked for the reform of this colonial act, its culture of patron client dynamics has still remained.
In democratic states, police are expected to treat all citizens fairly within the legal frameworks. However, in Bangladesh, political interference in policing practices is endemic, jeopardizing the ethos of law enforcement agencies. Over the years, the recruitment, deployment, and promotion of police officials have been directly influenced by ruling parties, in which loyalty and submission are more rewarded than professional skills and qualifications. Furthermore, the police have been motivated, weaponized, and used to suppress dissent and political opponents historically, which has led to the erosion of public trust and confidence in the police force.
Coming to what ought to be the main way forward, the police force in Bangladesh should be moved away from the colonial legacy of police structures to uphold people’s welfare and establish a culture of people-oriented policing. While long term reforms include a refined police act to prevent police officials from partisan controls, more short term or immediate reforms include accountability and a nature of resistance that confronts party power but ensures functionality.
Police have been motivated, weaponized, and used to suppress dissent and political opponents historically, which has led to the erosion of public trust and confidence in the police force
The police force should become an institution of the people, not the government. An independent and apolitical commission or oversight body should be formed to oversee police administration and protect it from misconduct, abuse of power, and political influences.
Such bodies have seen success in Japan (National Public Safety Commission) and England and Wales (Independent Office for Police Conduct) that investigate complaints against the police and ensure police operations remain free from political interference.
Recruitment, deployment, and promotion should prioritize transparency and integrity. While political-party membership is not allowed in government service, absolute autonomy from political influence of any nature is integral to be maintained. A separate system of recruiting in the police force (like in the case of military recruitment) is for instance an area of conversation.
The officials should be trained in crisis intervention, human rights, service values, and community policing to be more efficient and empathetic as well. There should be internal disciplinary units to ensure the conduct and ethical standards of the officials and to encourage them to report unethical pressure from the ruling political authorities without the fear of retaliation.
Indeed, Bangladesh needs to reach the point of achieving bold police reforms, which have far-reaching benefits, potentially elevating public trust and confidence in police and policing. With the check-and-balance of independence and oversight, an autonomous police force can be created. Actualization of this vision demands political will and courage, holistic support, and a well-thought-out approach to, by and for the state.
SS Salah Uddin Akash, is a final year student at the Department of Criminology, University of Dhaka. He is currently working on a research monograph on police reforms in Bangladesh.