Capital markets lie at the heart of any capitalist system. They are needed to spur growth and innovation. The promise of capital markets is to attract capital to the best ideas and talent, and thereby create growth.
Secondary markets are needed for liquidity, so people can unwind their investments or new investors can bring in new capital. It is therefore crucial to have functioning and thriving capital markets in any economy.
In Bangladesh, the capital markets are not very mature. The Dhaka and Chittagong stock exchanges only offer trading in equities and a very limited number of bonds. There are no provisions for trading options, futures, or any of the many standard instruments that you will find in more mature capital markets.
The more mature our capital markets become, the more likely foreign investors are to come in, because secondary markets offer downstream liquidity for them to exit their positions when they see fit.
As capital markets develop and grow, it becomes all the more important for a regulatory agency to oversee the trading activity and make sure that no rules are being broken and that markets are not being manipulated.
In virtually every market around the world, there is some form of Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that oversees these activities. In Bangladesh, this is the domain of the BSEC.
During the long tenure of the last government, the BSEC played a very dubious role. Rather than play the role of the market regulator who would catch and punish violators of market rules, members of the BSEC itself engaged in such behaviour for their own benefit.
In addition, although nowhere in their mandate, they bizarrely traveled the world on road shows at great cost, in a questionable and poorly executed attempt at drumming up interest in investing in Bangladesh.
For Bangladesh to develop mature and more sophisticated capital markets, serious reform is needed. This needs to go well beyond removing inappropriate rules that reduce liquidity, such as the floor prices on stocks. A comprehensive reform process is needed that follows best practices from around the world.
Before we can even begin focusing on the minute details such as the microstructure of the stock exchanges, we need to focus on the big picture.
When the regulator itself is so very corrupt, the reform process needs to begin with that agency itself. This is not simply a process of removing the leadership of that organization, just as simply changing the leadership of Bangladesh does not magically remove all the underlying corruption that is endemic to the country.
More than just fixing corruption, the BSEC needs serious reform that involves defining very clearly what its role is. In a very strange move, the BSEC decided to appoint the board members of the DSE. To be clear, the DSE is a private entity. The BSEC has no business appointing the board of a private entity. Its role is to regulate, not command who should run a business.
Of the five members of the Capital Markets Reform Task Force, only one has any actual experience in capital markets
Yet, not only did the BSEC appoint the directors of the DSE board, but they chose seven people, one of whom came from the military, and the other six have prior relationships with the BSEC chairman. The only thing all seven have in common is that none of them have any experience in capital markets or stock exchanges.
Clearly then, a capital markets reform task force is needed that will focus on all these issues, starting with the BSEC itself. Such a committee should be appointed by the government, presumably the Finance Ministry, but that is not what happened.
Instead, the BSEC itself appointed the capital markets reform task force. How can the agency which itself needs reform, appoint the task force that will focus on the reform? Obviously, this presents a blatant conflict of interest and pretty much guarantees that the BSEC will not get its needed reforms.
It actually gets worse. The task force that the BSEC appointed has five members. Each of these five members are distinguished and accomplished professionals in their respective fields, but therein lies the problem.
Three of the task force members are academics. One of them is a professor of economics, one is a professor of computer science, and the other is a professor of accounting and information systems. A fourth member of the task force is a partner at an accounting firm. The remaining member is a former MD of the Dhaka Stock Exchange.
Of the five members of the Capital Markets Reform Task Force, only one has any actual experience in capital markets. If you put together a team of the world’s best journalists, would you ask them to design and build a bridge? Would you drive across that bridge?
Interestingly, of the five members of the task force, three were originally appointed by the BSEC as DSE directors. They were later disqualified on technical issues, only to reappear on the task force for reform. If they were not qualified for the DSE, how are they qualified to oversee the broader capital markets reform process? There was no search committee or any attempt made to put qualified people on this task force.
There is no lack of qualified people who have a solid understanding of capital markets. In fact, the very topic of capital markets is so complex, that there are people who specialize in sub-fields of this, such as electronic trading, or market microstructure, for example.
They can be found both locally in Bangladesh and amongst the very accomplished diaspora worldwide. It is thus incomprehensible that the BSEC should be allowed to put together a reform task force and fill it with people who are clearly not suited for this particular task. The BSEC is the first thing that needs reform, followed by the actual markets. You cannot have one without the other.
Bangladesh needs functional and healthy capital markets. Even more so, it needs a trustworthy regulator that actually does its job. The government should appoint a competent task force with credible and experienced capital markets people to oversee the entire process.
There needs to be investigations into the extent of the transgressions of the BSEC in the past and punitive actions must be undertaken, otherwise the current and future regulators will feel like they have an open license to continue these practices. Numerous scams have happened in the mutual fund industry under the watch of the BSEC.
It is critically important to restore faith and confidence in our capital markets and this can only happen through fact finding committees and task forces that are appointed by the government, not by the very agency at the heart of many of the past misdeeds.