THE LAST WORD

Victory dance for forex

How glorious, we at this column get to do the Victory Dance. Note that it's we, a column is not the writer preaching, it is a collective endeavour between writer and readers. So, we collectively can celebrate that Bangladesh no longer has problems over foreign exchange reserves. Which is both good in itself and also something that we grasp here. No, no, none of us are arrogant enough to think that we, collectively, have changed the government's behaviour but we can pat ourselves on the back for having grasped what needed to be done and predicted what would happen if it were. 

The issue is that for some years now the country has been worrying about the number of US dollars (and, to a much lesser extent, other foreign currencies) the central bank has. The foreign money is needed to pay foreigners of course, for imports. So if there's a shortage of that, then we cannot buy the imports we need -- this would be bad. 

So, this is good news: “How the Taka is boosting forex reserves.” 

The background here is that in a free market we cannot have a shortage. Obviously, we can have high or low supply, high or low demand, but if prices are allowed to move freely then we cannot have an actual shortage. Because the price will move so that all of those who wish to supply do so, all of those who want at that price get. It's entirely -- wholly -- true that we might not like those prices but we cannot actually have a shortage at free market prices. 

The last government tried to control, for several years, the Taka-dollar foreign exchange rate. Not a lot, they weren't wholly absurd. But a bit. They thought that if $1 was worth -- just as an example you understand -- Tk100 then that would be good. Imports into Bangladesh would be cheaper, in Taka, than if the rate were Tk110 to the dollar. But -- again just as an example -- everyone who was not the government thought that the USD was actually worth Tk110.

So, very few people -- in fact, only those obliged to by law, and even many of them, not cheated, but didn't obey as wholly and as swiftly as perhaps they should have done -- sold their USD to the central bank and got Tk100 for each of them. They thought that 110 was a better price and either waited, or dealt around the side of the central bank and got something closer to what they thought was the right value. 

We have an open, free market, price for our currency. Therefore there is no shortage of our currency

Yes, of course, not obeying the law is bad. But that is what was happening. The result of this was that we had months, years, of worries about how the central bank's stock of dollars was falling. Because no one wanted to sell to them at the price they were offering. 

As this column pointed out a number of times this is because the price was being controlled. It's not possible to have a shortage like this at free market prices. Because anyone who wants more $ -- or more Tk -- can just buy and sell them at the free market price. 

So, what has happened now? The new government is still, a little bit, controlling the price of Tk. That's what a foreign exchange rate is, after all, the price of a currency. But they're controlling it very loosely. So loosely that they're really just stopping it from bouncing around. The exchange rate is, in fact, at its free market price. Around Tk120 to the dollar. At this price everyone who wants to sell Taka for dollars, and vice versa, can. 

Which is why the number of US dollars in the central bank is between stable and going up a bit. We have an open, free market, price for our currency. Therefore there is no shortage of our currency. Also, there is no shortage of that thing -- US dollars -- that we want to buy with our currency. 

If, when, we get prices right there are no shortages. We might not like those prices but if we attempt to insist upon them by law then we get those problems of that recent past, a shortage.

Now all we've got to do is make sure everyone understands this about all prices. But then no one ever did say that setting the world to rights was going to be easy, did they?      

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.