A one-sided protest?

In recent weeks, Bangladesh has witnessed a fresh wave of protests, particularly on university campuses, with students demanding the banning of the Awami League and its student wing, Chhatra League. 

These demonstrations, fueled by discontent over the controversies that erupted during the July-August 2024 revolution, have ignited debates about political accountability and governance. While the call for reforms is valid in the context of contemporary grievances, one glaring issue has been conspicuously overlooked: Jamaat-e-Islami’s dark role in Bangladesh’s 1971 Liberation War.

The demands to ban the Awami League, although rooted in today’s political context, fail to account for Jamaat-e-Islami’s well-documented complicity in the atrocities of 1971. This is a party whose active opposition to Bangladesh’s independence and collaboration with the Pakistani military resulted in the deaths of countless innocent people. 

The war crimes committed by Jamaat’s leadership, including mass murder, rape, and the systematic targeting of intellectuals, are a stain on the nation’s history. It is unsettling that these atrocities have been sidelined in the current protests, raising the question: Why the silence on Jamaat?

From March 26 to December 16, 1971, Bangladesh witnessed unimaginable horror, and Jamaat-e-Islami played a pivotal role in aiding the Pakistani military's brutal crackdown on freedom fighters and civilians alike. 

Jamaat members helped orchestrate one of the bloodiest chapters in modern history, directly participating in genocide and the assault on Bangladesh's independence movement. Many of Jamaat’s leaders were later tried and convicted of war crimes, but the legacy of their crimes remains largely unaddressed in today’s political discourse.If today's protesters are genuinely concerned about political accountability, why is there a selective focus on the Awami League? 

Jamaat’s unchecked presence in the political arena is a glaring omission that undermines the legitimacy of these protests. It is paradoxical to call for banning the Awami League while ignoring Jamaat’s undeniable role in the atrocities of 1971. Can the protesters truly claim to seek justice if they remain silent on this issue?

This silence speaks volumes and raises critical questions. Is it a result of ignorance or a conscious decision to overlook Jamaat’s war-time crimes? Perhaps the narrative of 1971, once a foundational pillar of Bangladesh’s national identity, has lost its significance among the new generation of activists. It is disturbing that while contemporary grievances dominate the conversation, the horrors of 1971 are being pushed aside. 

Jamaat-e-Islami’s quiet resurgence is a matter of grave concern. Over the years, the party has worked to distance itself from its wartime crimes, attempting to rebrand itself as a legitimate political force. But this rebranding should not deceive the public. Jamaat’s actions in 1971 are not a forgotten chapter; they are a stark reminder of what can happen when a party driven by extremist ideology is allowed to operate unchecked.

Criticism of the Awami League is, of course, valid, particularly when it concerns allegations of corruption, mismanagement, and the abuse of power. However, any call for political reform must come from a position of fairness and full accountability. Singling out the Awami League while ignoring Jamaat’s far more heinous past is not only selective outrage but a betrayal of the principles of justice that the protesters claim to champion.

The victims of 1971 deserve more than selective memory. The blood of martyrs, the trauma of those who were raped, and the anguish of families who lost loved ones at the hands of Jamaat members cry out for justice. The protesters’ silence on Jamaat’s role in the Liberation War is not just troubling, it is dangerous. It suggests that the horrors of the past can be conveniently forgotten if they do not fit into today’s political narrative.

If we are to engage in a conversation about banning political parties, it must be a comprehensive one. The Awami League’s current shortcomings do not absolve Jamaat-e-Islami of its crimes against the nation. Jamaat’s war-time actions, and its betrayal of Bangladesh during its struggle for freedom, demand condemnation and accountability. To ignore this history is to allow the wounds of 1971 to fester unhealed.

To the students and protesters, it is crucial to remember that justice is not achieved by addressing only one side of the issue. If the call is for the banning of the Awami League, then Jamaat-e-Islami must be included in that conversation. Their complicity in 1971’s atrocities cannot be erased, and their continued presence in Bangladesh’s political landscape is a travesty. 

While contemporary political grievances have sparked the current protests, the embers of history must never be ignored. Jamaat’s role in 1971 is an unhealed scar on the nation, and its silence in today’s debates is as concerning as it is dangerous. A full reckoning with our past is necessary if we are to move forward as a nation committed to justice. Anything less is an incomplete pursuit of truth and accountability.

 

Kollol Kibria is an Advocate, Human Rights Activist, and Political Analyst.